Book of the Week #2

Anthony Beevor – D-Day: The Battle for Normandy

Aside from the battle of Arnhem, and perhaps the battle of the Somme, D-Day is cerainly one of the most written about battles in military history. This book is the latest offering from Anthony Beevor, Author of Stalingrad and Berlin. The dustjacket offers ‘use of overlooked and new material… the most vivid and well-researched account yet’.  It also claims that Beevor’s narrative ‘conveys the true experience of war’, which is probably an unrealistic expectation for any book, no matter the author.

Beevor picks up from the fateful day on which Eisenhower made the decision to launch the Invasion, and then follows, in narrative, through to the Airborne assaults, the seaborne landings, the failure to capture Caen, the debacle at Villers Bocage, the breakout, the Falaise pocket and the libertion of Paris. Eminently readable and packed with details, Beevor makes use of veterans accounts, plentiful illustrations and some particularly detailed maps. If you knew absolutely nothing about the Battle of Normandy before picking up this book, you certainly would upon putting it down.

The promised groundbreaking research and new angles fail to deliver, sadly. If you already know about PLUTO, about Omaha, about Pegaus Bridge, Ham and Jam and Epson and Goodwood, there may not be all too much to interest you in this book. Beevor has clearly aimed more for the general interest market than students of the Second World War. Which is no bad thing by any means; but if you really want to get to grips with the arguments, the politics, and especially the post-war debates, you might be better served by reading books by Robin Neillands and/or Carlo D’Este. Any student of the Battle of Normandy will probably know that the battle has been raked over again and again, and there probably isnt too much new to offer unless new sources become available. But one thing Beevor’s thorough narrative has in abundance is a clear readability that should not put off the more casual reader.

D-Day: The Battle for Normandy

About these ads

41 Comments

Filed under Book of the Week, World War Two

41 responses to “Book of the Week #2

  1. papercutgirl

    I take exception to your interpretation because although Beevor does offer an overview, it is an overiew peppered with annecdotes and vignettes which do more to describe the political arguments than the cold arguments set forth by a more distant author. Also you cannot fault his attention to detail which does provide a far more visceral realtiy of the conflict than many of the above authors.

    Furthermore the book does not claim to provide an indepth assesment of the post-war situation and emerging politics – it is a narrative of that conflict. Nothing more.

    Having said that I am not a particular fan of Beevor’s and although some of his stuff is brilliant, I think his is often grossly overrated.

    Surely that has

  2. James Daly

    As someone who has read most – if not all – of the books about D-Day, when I first picked this book up, I felt that it offered nothing new that hadn’t already been published by other authors. Which is fine, as I mentioned in my review over a year ago, D-Day has been raked over and picked apart so much that theres probably not one document that hasnt been examined. But in that case, an author shouldn’t claim that his work is ground-breaking. I really wanted to like this book, and perhaps if I knew absolutely nothing about D-Day I would find it a useful start.

    The books out there by Carlo D’Este, Robin Neillands, Max Hastings, Robert Kershaw and Stephen Ambrose – not to mention the multitude of more detailed unit histories and more specialised books – go into more detail and in their time really were ground-breaking.

  3. I am no longer sure the place you’re getting your information, but good
    topic. I must spend some time studying more or working out more.
    Thanks for wonderful information I was looking for this information for my mission.

  4. Hi, I would like to subscribe for this blog to get most up-to-date
    updates, thus where can i do it please help out.

  5. Thank you for every other informative website. Where else could I am getting
    that kind of information written in such an ideal approach?
    I have a venture that I am just now running on, and I’ve been at the look out for such info.

  6. My wife and i were very happy Peter managed to conclude his survey via the ideas
    he gained when using the web site. It’s not at all simplistic
    to simply find yourself giving for free guidelines that many other people may have been
    trying to sell. And we also know we have the writer
    to be grateful to for that. The most important explanations you have made, the simple website menu, the relationships you make
    it easier to promote – it is many remarkable,
    and it’s really making our son and us reason why the matter is
    entertaining, and that is extraordinarily important.
    Many thanks for all the pieces!

  7. Thank you a lot for sharing this with all people you actually
    understand what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Kindly also seek advice
    from my web site =). We will have a link exchange arrangement
    among us!

  8. The movie is all about the personal life of J and the general public.
    No need to download any extra software to download the stuff
    from our site. Singling out one performance listed here is not enough.

  9. Unlike other programs, it is still going after 8 months.
    Thus, have the list and book these great films from
    a video shop on your children to savor. He gives up his or her own life within the
    distinct work.

  10. This Really Is another good movie that you can download to your iPod.
    The video also features Willem Dafoe and Reese Witherspoon.
    To plan ahead for that, the Yankees have declared C.C.

  11. Therefore, do not expect that you can watch live streaming anytime you wish.
    Armed with web connection, you are able to enjoy both saved and loading version of the free TV shows.

  12. This Really Is simply a notice asking when you
    can send a script to the developer. Another winner in the
    endlessly inventive people at Pixar. Most of them come across as standard, with regular problems and
    issues.

  13. This can be a system that as a closing stage addresses the principal reasons people fail at fat
    loss. But this game just gets the experience of somewere between a half and twelve games this year i saw this team-play.

  14. The way you say it is going to make all the difference in the second.
    Sometimes humor is the key to landing your girl.
    The way in the direction of accurate realization of oneself is by loving an additional individual.

  15. Particular films become thus viral, they distribute worldwide.
    This Really Is needless to say the crux of the problem. I understand
    that I lose brain cells and moment by enjoying these
    kinds of shows but I do appreciate them.

  16. You can obtain to your hearts content, or when your iphone memory is complete.

    It took lengthier for hackers to jailbreak the iphone five and iOS
    6.x than for any previous telephone.

  17. Shutter is a Japanese cat movie and is completely the scariest movie
    I have ever seen – bar-none. Maybe you have already-built-up your personal thriller DVD videos collection?
    It really is fairly reliable and safe.

  18. On the display you can view the AM/FM tunes and alarm setting, or the time and date.
    As soon as the operation is complete, the user will get complete
    accessibility to the iPod’s system. How about personalizing the way you send messages.

  19. I want to to thank you for this fantastic read!!

    I certainly enjoyed every bit of it. I’ve got you
    book-marked to look at new things you post…

  20. Nonetheless it is more difficult than utilizing
    an iPhone or iPad and takes longer to use. This is
    totally legitimate, it is amazingly easy to use due to the touch screen software.

  21. One other popular exhibits are Jyoyi, Seeta
    and Geeta, and Meera. Furthermore, Twitter’s trending matters typically catches the recognition of specific tv shows.
    Not absolutely all reality shows are manufactured precisely the
    same.

  22. Heading to the World Series Game 3, the Phillies are right where they wished to be.

    MindBody will assist you wake-up feeling rested and alert.

    AMC purchased out the theater from Kerasote and that promotion ended.

  23. This will be the most inexpensive option for you if some thing has happened to your
    Apple iphone. Benefits of an unlocked iphone 3GS go much previous totally free applications.
    First, the product arrives with an impressive reward.

  24. It employs your cellphones data connection or internet connection for the pointless people.

    Rushkoff believes that people may forsake Facebook and only genuine property websites, but I differ.

  25. The Kerasote $5 movie ticket went far from the Olde Town Arvada Theatre previous month.
    They try to support folks who are hunted by tones or stalked
    by ghosts. It’s going to carry the world, one back-alley at a time!

  26. It’s an remarkable paragraph in favor of all the web
    people; they will obtain benefit from it I am sure.

  27. Along with it you will want to just eliminate your cable TV account
    and save yourself a number of money. Adventure takes regulations into his or her
    own hands and becomes the Punisher.

  28. Tim Robbins as Andy Dufresne and Morgan Freeman as “Red” are simply excellent.

    One of the latest laptops introduced by HCL could be the HCL MiLeap xseries.
    No surprise they become one of many greatest displays.

  29. Jack Nicholson’s descent into madness is wonderfully acted and equally alarming.
    She teaches them to play and appreciate their behavior betters, and music.
    Do not network making use of their guest and steal their magic.

  30. These on-line Barbie games are very addictive.

    Place a little little bit of tape about the ring
    and blindfold the initial kid to play. That makes sports games very easy to find and that makes their worth very
    little.

  31. If you do not personal an Iphone, purchase one;
    the price might be a little bit more but it is the new
    thing. As soon as the procedure is total, the consumer
    gets full access to the iPod’s method.

  32. PsP handhelds are one of many hottest and most fun ways to play games, watch movies and tune
    in to audio. Some of those sites don’t have any limit
    to the amount of packages you do every day.

  33. The ipad 2 leather case has been intended to absorb the bumps that could cause possible injuries.
    As after you go for a reset there is no way you may bring each of the deleted data back.
    But why jailbreak is actually a good question.

  34. The Chronic Dev Group has launched the greenpois0n untethered Jailbreak for iOS four.2.one.
    Obtaining into the Apple iphone shop is not that
    difficult and the applications are actually fairly simple.

  35. The problem if permitted to proceed will cause
    damage to the lungs. This helped me to eat more vegetables and
    calcium-rich foods as required for nursing my kid. Nutritional control
    in type 1 diabetes is essential.

  36. There is a catch, however, to buying the vehicle.
    Foster is nothing in short supply of a bad-ass in
    this picture. Robinson” or Scott’s gospel-tinged Michael Jackson song? After their talk, Todd receives Walter’s phone call.

  37. Viewing your preferred cinema with the entire family is different experience altogether.
    Maybe it’s a dilemma about how to get strength in adversity.
    Memberships can be found in many phrases.

  38. First off I want to say terrific blog! I had a quick question
    in which I’d like to ask if you do not mind.
    I was interested to know how you center yourself and clear your
    thoughts before writing. I have had a hard time clearing my thoughts
    in getting my thoughts out. I do take pleasure in writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes tend to be lost simply just trying
    to figure out how to begin. Any recommendations or tips?
    Cheers!

  39. So, what does Twitter say concerning the state of the TV market
    nowadays? In 1971, an all black school is combined with an all
    white school produced a racial battle at T.C.

  40. But, comparing to the mentioned before choice, this really is way
    a lot better than that. Given the long list above, you’ve enough reasons to enjoy the-art of cinematography.
    And, needless to say, mentioned monster incorrect.

  41. These are really great films and you need to certainly view them.
    Fantastic mixture of music and the modest style which Von Trier is
    becoming recognized for. Thus, what does Facebook reveal
    about shows?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s