Tommy by Richard Holmes

Richard Holmes was, in my eyes, unique. As a military man and an academic historian, he actually managed to capture the public’s imagination with his work. I can think of no other academic military historian who has reached out to society at large like Holmes. And surely, that is a fine, fine achievement.

As Holmes himself states in his preface, his initial military history interests involved researching battles and generals. Note his accomplished biographies of Marlborough, Wellington and French. But along the way he developed an interests in the ordinary man at war, and this led to his series of books such as Redcoat, and this book, which I consider to be his greatest achievement.

It does not have the revisionism of a writer such as Corrigan, and historiographically it sits in between narrative and probing challenges of the perceived wisdom. It is emminently readable and makes prolific use of first hand sources. But what I think is the real achievement here, is that Holmes has examined pretty much every aspect of war on the Western Front, and successively passed them all under a historical microscope. He doesn’t fall into the trap of hindsight, but neither does he go for hero worship or a bland recasting of earlier works.

The subjects that Holmes covers are vast, and some are not for the faint of heart – crime, punishment, homosexuality, venereal disease, honours, ranks, officer-men relations, attitudes to the war, food, drink (alcoholic and non-alcoholic), uniforms, lice, mud, weapons, training, and so on. In fact no stone is left unturned; there is no literary no-mans land here.

Holmes’ progression from a soldier, to an academic military historian, to a social military historian, is perhaps the best example possible of how military history itself is evolving. Not only has the field opened up beyond career soldiers alone, but we are more and more interested in the experiences of the common man – the millions of Tommies – rather than the deliberations of a few middle aged men who sat at the top of the tree. Perhaps this is a reflection of a change in modern society overall. As a military historian with both feet firmly in social history, I can only hope that this movement continues.

This book is a military history tour de force, by the late great Professor. It is the kind of book that makes me, as a historian, hope that I could one day write a book 5% as good as this. This is exactly the kind of book to get historians in the right frame of mind for the centenary projects looming in the next couple of years. It’s going to sit on my bookshelf for some time to come.



Filed under Army, Book of the Week, western front, World War One

9 responses to “Tommy by Richard Holmes

  1. Books like these are a multiple blessing. They not only give the history of a conflict, they draw in people that now-dead veterans and their stories would have enthralled, and they make excellent reference material for those in the re-enactment and wargaming areas (a small minority, but an important one). As a representative of the tale-seekers and the re-enactors, I am very happy to see such a detailed volume – even if some of the details get a little, well, TOO detailed! 🙂

  2. Also, companies are already lowering cost of product as
    they try to compete for your business. This is due to the nature of sea water is
    said to be unpredictable. WAAS is actually a fantastic aspect to look
    for when purchasing for discount marine GPS.

  3. Many good people stay to select the most effective television shows of 2008.
    It absolutely was merely provided a typical score as a car or truck
    by a major automotive site I went also.

  4. The essential idea is when the music begins each
    child must dance around. Lumber of every shade and structure is
    available to make probably the most beautiful floors.
    This exciting website I used last year for my children.

  5. However The problem is, “are you going to obtain the best deal”?
    Discovering and iPhone sale could be challenging.
    You’ll need certainly to join eventually, so it’s best to do it the moment possible.

  6. Wow, incredible blog layout! How long have you been blogging
    for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is excellent,
    as well as the content!

  7. Have you ever considered about including a little bit more than just your
    articles? I mean, what you say is valuable and all.
    Nevertheless imagine if you added some great visuals or videos to give your posts more,
    “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and video
    clips, this website could certainly be one of the
    most beneficial in its field. Good blog!

  8. It often takes a big bit from your budget that is fundamental.
    This will redirect one to a webpage or site. And, ofcourse,
    Peter Pan continues to be retold being a musical.

  9. If the web web page is wider to match the display, then the user
    has to move it to view the contents. How they promised that the iPhone Dev
    Group launched a new version of Pwnage Resources for everyone
    to download.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s