‘A very fine Commander’: the memoirs of Sir Horatius Murray (edited by John Donovan)

‘your memoirs, Nap? Who on earth do you think would want to read them?’

So said Field Marshal Montgomery, when General Horatius Murray suggested writing his recollections of a lifetimes service. Indeed, military memoirs can be very hit or miss, usually the latter. Especially when written by a family member or close friend. I’ve got to be honest, I wasn’t too excited about reading this book – the memoirs of a General I had never heard of. But in actual fact, Horatius Murray’s memoirs made for a very interesting read, giving a great insight into the career of a pre-war officer, mid-level command in the Second World War, and then post-war command in Korea, Scottish Command and NATO’s Northern Command in Scandinavia.

You would expect somebody called Horatius to have served in the Guards, a dashing Cavalry Regiment or perhaps the Rifles. In fact Murray came from a relatively modest family, and only just manged to afford to go to Sandhurst. Although he performed well there, without sufficient private means he was forced to join a relatively unglamorous unit, the Cameronian Rifles. It shows the differing pace of soldiering in peace and war that from when he was commissioned in 1923 it took Murray until 1938 to become a Major, yet by 1944 he was an acting Major-General. Some of his early years as an officer were spent serving in Egypt, India and China. Interestingly, he also spent several months on attachment with the Germany Army only a couple of years before the Second World War broke out.

Horatius Murray commanded a Gordon Highlanders Battalion at El Alamein, where he was seriously wounded, then recovered in time to resume command in the final days of the Tunisian Campaign. He was then given command of a Brigade in the invasion of Sicily. In late 1943 the 51st Highland Division returned to Britain to take part in Operation Overlord. A follow up Division, the Highlanders landed in Normandy on 7 June 1944. In Normandy the Division performed rather poorly, in Murray’s opinion due to poor leadership and a lack of serious training. At one point Murray refused an order from the Divisional Commander, Major General Bullen-Smith, that he thought was needless and would waste mens lives. The Corps Commander ruled in Murray’s favour, recommended Bullen-Smith’s sacking, which Monty confirmed soon after. This undoubtedly showed great moral courage on Murray’s part. Shortly after landing in Normandy Murray was transferred to Italy to take command of 6th Armoured Division, which he led until the end of the war.

After the war he served as commander of the 1st Division, Director of Personnel at the War Office and commanded the 50th (Northumbrian) Division, a territorial unit based in Catterick. After leaving that post he was selected to command the Commonwealth Division in Korea. Although this came in 1953 after the ceasefire, Murray still commanded British, Australian, Canadian and New Zealand troops in peacekeeping. Murray seems to have been a very modest General, to the point of not even mentioning in his memoirs his DSO and other brave acts – his Nephew added notes in when editing. He seems to have had no airs nor graces. Indeed, when he left command of the 50th Division based at Catterick, the local newspaper reported that he had given the camp a soldiers touch.

Also included are some very revealing ancedotes about King George VI, Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother, Monty, Eisenhower, Bernard Freyberg VC and Maxwell Taylor. I cannot recall many other books that I picked up with such disinterest, yet finished with such an insight. I enjoyed reading them immsensely.

‘A very fine Commander’ is published by Pen and Sword



Filed under Army, Book of the Week, Uncategorized, World War Two

10 responses to “‘A very fine Commander’: the memoirs of Sir Horatius Murray (edited by John Donovan)

  1. John Erickson

    This sounds like a fascinating read. Especially anything about the Commonwealth troops in Korea – so many reference books treat Korea as “U.S. and ROK vs. NK and China”. And I have to admit that, although I haven’t heard of this man, the book makes him sound like one of those rare “soldiers’ Generals”. I hope I can get a copy over here! 🙂

  2. Pingback: food waste disposer

  3. Its service record is also an active member car 4 sale of the IBC Japan
    Research Team. Most car dealerships will try to hide repairs.
    The phrase,” enthusiast owned” shows up a fair amount of stuff.
    Moreover, those companies are often associated with the car that you wish to drive.
    The best value on a car lot, get your credit report, depriving you an
    opportunity for improving credit score.

  4. It can be boring sometimes but I prefer to see
    what it is that successful people search for within their employees.
    The picture shows how American teenagers will talk above and beyond their achievements.

  5. Add sweetener and cocoa powder, and stir before you have a
    smooth heavy syrup. I unhappy my guard throughout
    that moment, and I’d begun to restore a few of the formerly lost lbs back.

  6. I love these and believe they make the right party
    favor. She believed that up allon her own – gotta supply credit to
    the kid. I actually do think that your search is finally over.

  7. Here are a few suggestions for a diabetes-free lifestyle.

    Three, balanced dinners should be eaten by you
    together with two treats everyday. I am not even attempting to have a baby

  8. If you are going for finest contents like myself, only pay a quick visit this web site all the time since it presents feature contents, thanks

  9. What the heck i just read? The 1st factor is to consult
    the physician before using this product. The extract
    of Forskolin is accessible such as pills and tablets and contacting the physician will provide you a clear know-how about
    the fact will it suit you or not. This supplement generally satisfies the requirements of the people but exceptions are normally there.

    So, you have to make sure that you are not the one which
    are unable to use this solution. Another problem is concerning the dose.
    You need to question your medical professional regarding the absorption and
    be special about this authentic Forskolin.
    WOW.Nice read here. The important key to how the
    product gets results is it can be a dual-action diet
    solution, meaning that it works as an appetite reducing aid plus a “fat burner”.
    This definitely signifies that it oxidizes fat cells by using anti-oxidants, and this ends up in additional
    vitality for yourself – although only when know how taking authentic Forskolin in the suitable style.The majority of diet products on the market
    today are made around reving up your fat
    burning capacity, which is not really safe for many people – and this is the
    reason why so many people decide to invest in Forskolin extract instead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s