Guthrie’s War: A Surgeon of the Peninsula and Waterloo by Michael Crumplin

I’m not the greatest of people with squeamish stuff – graphic descriptions of nasty wounds make me toes curl. I studied ‘medicine through time’ for GCSE History, and even then medical history, although interesting, would make my stomach churn. Yet despite that, I could never deny that Medical History is interesting. Its at an intersection between history and science. And more often than not, most medical advances are inspired by war. And this book is a prime of example of a skilled medic who honed his skills during war time.

George Guthrie is one of the unsung heroes of the Napoleonic Wars. Not only was he one of the most forward thinking surgeons of his time, he also kept detailed case records and statistics, which here are edited by Michael Crumplin, himself a retired surgeon.

There are some pretty gruesome cases described here. Its not surprising that terrible wounds shock us, as most Hollywood films show the hero being shot cleanly through the heart, saying ‘tell Jane that I love her’ and then lolloping his head to one side. As Guthrie shows, bullets do not make nice neat holes, neither do swords. As a Historian I would be pretty much lost trying to make sense of some of the more scientific details, so its a smart move for Guthrie’s account to be edited by a doctor.

War gives the surgeon many more opportunities to examine the human anatomy, that in peacetime would only come from dissecting dead bodies. And the opportunity to get to grips with complex trauma wounds led to discoveries and innovations – Guthrie found that when amputating limbs a tourniquet was not always necessary, and that all an assitant needed to do was apply firm pressure on the right arteries. Guthrie also developed an understanding of how to run hospitals with minimising the risk of infection and disease in mind.

We often find that the treatment and suffering of wounded during wars brings about a national outcry – particularly the Crimean War, the First World War and to a lesser extent the current Afghan War and Help for Heroes. The Napoleonic Wars might not have caused a revolution in nursing like the Crimea, nor the forming of charities such as after 1918. But its effects were more subtle – slowly, the authorities began to see the importance of good medical services to warfighting. Much as Wellington won his battles partly through solid logistical organistation, he also made medical services an inherent part of planning, and not just a bolt-on.

Interestingly, it seems that Guthrie came up opposition from his contemporaries, particularly on his policy of only amputating when absolutely necessary. If we believe other contemporary accounts – such as Bernard Cornwell’s Sharpe series, and also accounts of Naval surgery, it would seem that Napoleonic military surgeon’s were knife-happy butchers.

Maybe the historical convention that all Napoleonic-era military surgeons were butchers needs to be re-thought? There also seems to be a convention that the only Napoleonic doctor with any kind of forward-thinking was the Empereur’s personal surgeon, Dr Larrey. Yet this account of Guthrie’s war service suggest that medical science in the British Army was not as barbaric as we might immediately think.

Guthrie’s War is published by Pen and Sword



Filed under Army, Book of the Week, Napoleonic War, Uncategorized

14 responses to “Guthrie’s War: A Surgeon of the Peninsula and Waterloo by Michael Crumplin

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Guthrie’s War: A Surgeon of the Peninsula and Waterloo by Michael Crumplin « Daly History Blog --

  2. I must thank you for the efforts you’ve put in writing
    this blog. I am hoping to view the same high-grade blog posts from you later on as well.
    In fact, your creative writing abilities has motivated
    me to get my own website now 😉

  3. From a thriller to a biography and comedy to journey. The record has classic
    movies like Noise of the Audio and latest movies like Up, which
    are essential view for kids. In the event that you haven’t viewed, please do!

  4. There are five Death Wish movies, all starring Charles Branson.

    There are stations for sports, information, family entertainment, and Infotainment.
    High-Fidelity-John Cusack again performs a job he’s made

  5. Whether Apple will current other new products at the presentation
    of the Apple iphone 5, is still unclear. If you want to send the gadget to Apple for restore,
    you can restore the authentic options of the telephone.

  6. An increasing number of people are making use of mobile for both- surfing the internet and creating purchases.
    Now it stays to be noticed how Apple reacts to this scenario.
    The Apple iphone has eight GB of built-in memory.

  7. Instead, they make investments a entire great deal of money to buy a brand name new one for on their own.
    They are so dependent on the Iphone that they just cant have the
    persistence to get it repaired.

  8. There are two very good applications known as iBlacklist and our extremely own Google Voice App.
    Operating Method – With the Apple iphone four, you get the Iphone OS.

    However, most phones aren’t considered perfect.

  9. Although not so great it may surpass the Notebook.

    It is a good way to make kids helps in increasing their language and learn new phrases.
    You will find how to utilize ultrasn0w 1.2.3 here.

  10. The nice ideas are ultimately applied to the state software via updates.
    A lot of the applications will be the same, but iOS possesses you more choice.
    You could disconnect the telephone from the computer now.

  11. Useful information. Fortunate me I found your web site unintentionally, and I’m shocked why this twist of fate didn’t came about earlier!
    I bookmarked it.

  12. Jumping beans have usually been a popular novelty.

    You can location small widgets and shortcuts to your preferred
    applications on the home screen. The problem lies in this particular
    model of iPod.

  13. Maybe you have realized that new visitors to face-book nonetheless even today,
    are ignorant how private it is? Install and operate the free
    Advanced IP Scanner tool. Added a connect to your Page within your email signature?

  14. You’ll find two kinds of jailbreak s; untethered in addition to connected.

    No-one jailbreak software works for several designs of the
    iPhone. That app with all the renowned star that is brown could
    be the Cydia application.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s