Kept in the Dark by John Stubbington

This forensic and incisive book by Wing Commander John Stubbington takes a comprehensive view of the intellingence – or lack of it – provided to Bomber Command during the Second World War.

It’s pretty much common knowledge nowadays that for the last few years of the war the allies were able to intercept the Germans Enigma Signals, and the decryptions of these signals were known as ULTRA. Of course, some sterling work went on at Bletchley Park by men such as Alan Turing and by British submariners in capturing Enigma codebooks. Perhaps the most well-known use of ULTRA intelligence was defeating the U-Boat menace during the Battle of the Atlantic, something that has been well described by John Terraine in The U-Boat Wars.

But having such a rich seem of intelligence is one thing, making good use of it is quite another. And we don’t ever hear much about the misuse of ULTRA intelligence – one of the most prominent in my mind if the debacle of Arnhem, where intercepts clearly placed the Panzer Divisions around Arnhem, but it seems that this fact was not passed down to the commanders who really needed to know the fact. And as Stubbington shows here, a similar situation existed in the RAF, where the Air Ministry, incredibly, did not pass on ULTRA intelligence to Bomber Command and its Chief, Sir Arthur Harris. Its even more incredible when we consider that his American counterparts at the US Eight Air Force had full access to ULTRA.

Why were Harris and Bomber Command kept out of the loop? It seems to have been down to a complex set of parochial and political issues pervading within the RAF. The existence of a Director of Bombing Operations at the Air Ministry, who was openly hostile to Harris, created tension that possibly led to a holding back of intelligence. A plethora of committees, departments and commanders in Whitehall and beyond were continually bickering about targets – Oil, transportation, U-Boat pens, dehousing etc – led to a lack of common purpose within the RAF. This lack of purpose made it all the more easy for Harris’s enemies to ensure that he did not receive ULTRA intelligence, that may well have informed and shaped his operational planning. To not pass ULTRA intelligence on to a commander of Harris’s level was most unusual, and must beg the question why.

Another argument that Stubbington advances is that perhaps Harris was seen as too unreliable to be trusted with ULTRA. There is no evidence to suggest that Harris was a security risk, and in any case if any officer cannot be trusted, should they really be in command anyway? There is no evidence to suggest that ULTRA was witheld for this reason, but my hunch is that it is a reason that could well have been quietly expounded by Harris’s enemies. Time and time again we read that the allies were paranoid about the ULTRA secret leaking out, to the extent of witholding its benefits from key officers.

Would ULTRA intelligence have made much of a difference to Bombing Operations, had Harris been in receipt of it? Stubbington suggests here that ULTRA decrypts would have shown just how pivotal the destruction of Germany’s transportation system was. ULTRA might have made Harris better armed when it came to arguing over target policy. And by denying the commander most responsible for directing the Bomber offensive the most valuable source of intelligence available, the whitehall warriors were commiting a shameful act.

This is a most insightful book by Wing Commander Stubbington. It draws on a wealth of original research and uses a wide range of sources, and it will infom the historiography of ULTRA and wartime intelligence, and also the controversial history of the Bomber Offensive.

Kept in the Dark is published by Pen and Sword



Filed under Book of the Week, Intelligence, Royal Air Force, World War Two

15 responses to “Kept in the Dark by John Stubbington

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Kept in the Dark by John Stubbington « Daly History Blog --

  2. whoah this blog is magnificent i really like studying
    your posts. Stay up the good work! You already know, a lot of persons are searching round for this information, you could help them

  3. Now, 20 years later, they’re back together to perform at the WKLN public access
    TV station telethon. Thermoplastic polyesters are the most demanded form off polyesters with vast applications in engineering
    industry. Laboratories are increasing the efficiency of nylon fiber,
    so that it becomes more durable and tougher, providing greater resistance to stains.

  4. It employs your mobile phones info connection or web connection
    for the boring people. The first step in network marketing on
    Facebook is always to open a totally free account.

  5. Free over-sized tops could be teamed with hot-pants.
    It’s based on the idea that distributed practice
    is needed by learners. They’ll get shot if they do not follow this strategy.

  6. Some exhibits decrease of over-time, and then start with quite high viewership.
    RealVideo(RM), QuickTime (MOV) and Windows Media (WMV).
    HCL is just a leading organization in India within the
    area of computer and computer related products.

  7. The gadget is ultra skinny as it is only 12 mm thick. And The Michael Jackson Design Plastic
    Hard Back Case is fanciful and full of inspiration.
    This vehicle adapter package is the ultimate new Apple iphone accessory.

  8. The established comes with 3 sizes of ear buds to assist you to discover the best
    match. The Apple Apple iphone is much more than just your
    average mobile phone. You will need the IMEI for performing
    all this.

  9. As it happens more than you feel, so long as you focus on more
    serious initiatives. Holddown the ALT button and push the RECOVER
    button in iTunes in the same moment. It’s simple to create, effective and simple to
    make use of.

  10. Though it does not offer much in the way of new capabilities, it has been made slightly
    more straightforward to use. I identified Safari to become
    highly-responsive and fast to load just about anything, and visited many of
    my regular haunts.

  11. You make them subscription based and can also build applications that are considerably sophisticated.
    They struck on the stand easily and start targeting in effect.
    What I’m discussing isn’t simply revolution.

  12. excellent points altogether, you just gained a new reader.
    What may you recommend in regards to your post that you simply made some days in the past?
    Any sure?

  13. Everything is very open with a precise clarification of the challenges.

    It was really informative. Your site is extremely helpful.
    Many thanks for sharing!

  14. If you have carried out any of these things then you have currently utilized cloud
    technology. The question is, do carriers lose money on these deals.
    DROPBOX (Totally free)Backup your information or share paperwork.

  15. This indicates an overpowering number of smartphones in the hands of consumers.
    IPad2 is one of the very best gadget of Apple and it can be easily
    jailbreak. Do you have an iphone problem and need solutions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s