Defence Green Paper predicts tough choices and big changes

The Defence Secretary Bob Ainsworth today published a Green Paper ahead of the upcoming Strategic Defence Review. It can be read in full here.

Titled ”Adaptability and Partnership: Issues for the Strategic Defence Review’, the paper sets the terms of reference for the tough review on Defence spending and policy that is due to take place after the next General Election.

Obviously, the more discussion, debate and thinking that goes into shaping the review, the better. I do question how worthwhile Defence-based discussion will be, as the review is bound to be driven by Treasury policy. None the less, It is important for the Government, the MOD and the services to take a serious look at the issues involved.

Key Questions outlined are:

  • What contribution can the Armed Forces make to internal security within the UK?
  • How can the Armed Forces be more effective in supporting conflict prevention?
  • Do our international relationships need rethinking?
  • How closely should our armed forces integrate with allies?

The paper seems to conclude that the Armed Forces will have to become leaner and meaner, and to not become too focussed on specific threats but be able to react to new ones. The paper also underlines firmly that the days of the UK acting alone are long gone, and that in future all operations will be in partnership with allies. This will involve building closer links with the US and Europe in particular. This represents a huge change in sovereignty as we know it – the UK is no longer able to defend itself alone. Is this a reflection of changing international circumstances? Clearly, however, some big changes will have to take place.

The most perplexing conclusion of the review is that foreign policy, defence and international development should be more closely integrated. Why has this been dreamt up all of a sudden? The Iraq Inquiry has shown just how disparate these Government Departments have been. Especially when dealing with asymetric threats that require civil and military co-operation. This is especially sad, as the UK had long led the field in low-intensity warfare.

Defence Secretary Bob Ainsworth said: “There is no more important function for Government than Defence. This Green Paper will stimulate debate about the future of Britain’s defence ahead of a Strategic Defence Review in the next Parliament. Afghanistan is the top priority today but we must also ensure that our Armed Forces are ready to confront the challenges of tomorrow. The current and emerging threats we face are characterised by uncertainty and will require a more flexible response from an adaptable Armed Forces.”

Chief of the Defence Staff, Air Chief Marshal Sir Jock Stirrup, said: “I welcome this Green Paper. It is a first and a significant step on the road to the forthcoming Defence Review that will shape our security in the years ahead. The issues the Green Paper raises are of fundamental importance to all citizens of this country, and I look forward to a vigorous and widespread debate on them in the coming months.”

One does wonder, however, just how much input Sideshow Bob and His Airship Sir Jock will have into the review – for one, the Defence Secretary after May will probably be Tory. Will the Treasury simply hand the MOD cuts and expect them to make them? Probably. It is particularly galling for Ainsworth to talk about Defence as the most important function for the Government – this is not borne out in spending or decision making.

All the same, there will probably be some sharp debates over the next few months. Given the tribal nature of British armed forces expect to see the heads of the Navy, Army and Air Force to attempt to outdo each other. While this loyalty is admirable, it comes at the expense of a broader ‘UK Defence’ thinking. Loyalty should not come before objectivity. Units such as the RAF Regiment, for example, should not escape just because the RAF stamps its feet to keep it. Current expectations are that the RAF and Navy will bear the brunt of the cuts, but who knows what clever lobying may bring about?



Filed under Afghanistan, Army, debate, defence, Navy, News, politics, Royal Air Force

15 responses to “Defence Green Paper predicts tough choices and big changes

  1. Mike Burleson

    “The paper also underlines firmly that the days of the UK acting alone are long gone, and that in future all operations will be in partnership with allies.”

    Haven’t we been hearing this theme since the 1950s? Really, NO NATION goes it alone in the modern world, especially the Western allies, and why should we? Despite our numerous disagreements, we always seem to be there for one another when it really counts. Therein is our strength.

  2. James Daly

    I do think that the howls of ‘we cant defend ourselves’ will get in the way of people realising that multilateral action is not only the best way to go to war politically, but militarily too. The modern world is such a joined-up place in so many ways, maybe the old geo-political borders aren’t as relevant nowadays?

    Think Defence ran an article some time ago advocating that nations within a partnership or alliance could specialise in certain areas, which is quite possibly what the UK may have to do.

  3. Let’s hope it isn’t just driven by the Treasury.

  4. James Daly

    I suspect given the current economic climate and the need to cut public spending that the treasury’s voice will be heard loud and clear. I suspect that the next Government will hand each Department a target for cuts and let them get on with it, which will mean th forces squabbling with each other… again…

  5. Did you know you can count on to provide you with acknowledgement of the used car in terms of servicing, insurance or additional enhancements?
    Often these businesses are willing to advantage your further prep.
    Correspondingly, a 48 month used car loans. We also provide a free car
    qualifier no obligation assessment. A flood damaged car may
    be even more long-lasting than the new ones.

  6. This is for anyone that actually would like to get out of under AT&T’s thumb.
    Make use of a Movie Distinct ProxyA proxy allows for common records
    to be crammed onto its servers.

  7. Thats why I personally use a niche site named fullmovies since the buy in payment
    is next to nothing. Traffic-Steven Soderbergh got a lot of
    deserved attention for hisAmerican adaptationof a Danish miniseries, Traffik.

  8. There are numerous other kinds of Iphone consumer apps as nicely.

    Steve Work basically reiterated the issues and defined what Apple was
    doing to repair the problem. Subscribe to his column by clicking here.

  9. Jetpack Jailbreak is an entertaining game and fantastic for brief function breaks.
    It supports stereo Buletooth, and the music high quality is commendable.
    I just obtained a new blackberry after sampling and contemplating telephones.

  10. Whilst the more recent edition is released, the older edition is dropped down to $99 for an 8 gig.

    Subscribe to his column by clicking here. Comtrya!
    Yes, this is a easy 1, looks just like the Apple’s alarm clock.

  11. Thanks for this amazing post, I am glad I discovered this web site on the search engines.

  12. This is a fantastic application if your kids have the iTouch and no mobile phone.
    Thin wallets are in need for each males and women. One of those applications is the songs player.

    Android was built to be open up from the leap.

  13. Fetele iubesc domina relatia , mai ales atunci când vine vorba de pozitii sexuale .
    Nu e nimic ca reconfortant ca o pisică de dormit în poala mea în timp ce am citit o carte excelenta .
    Aceasta într-adevăr este motivul pentru care există rețele sociale mature .

  14. Acesta este secolul modern, în care nu există domeniu de aplicare
    larg pentru căsătorii și asociații interrasiale . Atingeți pielea ta la pielea
    ei în moduri neobișnuite și distincte . Chiar merge la
    malul marii ar putea fi un conflict .

  15. That is very fascinating, You are an excessively professional blogger.
    I have joined your rss feed and stay up for seeking
    extra of your great post. Additionally, I
    have shared your site in my social networks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s