Britain ‘faces world choice’

Britain still has a taste for being a world power – and a determination to be a key influence on the United States, a senior defence analyst has told the BBC. But it faces a choice on how to play out that role, says Michael Codner, head of military sciences at the Royal United Services Institute.

With a general election looming and both Labour and the Tories promising to hold an early Strategic Defence Review, big questions are bound to be asked about the future of the armed forces. Structures, equipment, procurement, all depend on what exactly we plan to do with our soldiers, sailors and airmen. As war is essentially the pursuit of politics through other means, the need to form a policy on our use of defence in foreign affairs is paramount. Two big projects are likely to come under close scrutiny – the new Aircraft Carriers and our Nuclear deterrent.

One option would be to scale back on our spending, and become more of an ordinary European power, and plan to only take part in action as part of a NATO or EU alliance. This would see us lose much of our independent expeditionary capability. Whilst this would be cheaper, it would leave places such as the Falklands vulnerable, and our ability to co-operate with and influence the US would be much reduced.

Another choice would be to retrench even further and only retain the forces necessary to defend the UK, our sea lanes and our air space. But in an increasingly globalised world, this would not be feasible. History has proven that to deliver security at home you sometimes have to act further afield – Afghan poppy fields and Indian Ocean sea lanes are cases in hand.

One policy, which Mr Codner favours, is what defence experts call “strategic raiding” in which British forces are able to intervene swiftly and with a high degree of independence. It places a high value on naval and air forces for “theatre entry and sea basing”, and specialist light infantry. The classic “strategic raiding” operation, he says, is the successful British intervention in Sierra Leone in 2000.

The fly in the ointment is Britain’s long-term commitment to involvement in Afghanistan. As long as we are committed to fighting in Helmand, that must quite rightly take priority in resources. But in the even-longer term, we need to leave ourselves balanced and flexible enough to meet future threats. And of course, future threats do not often give us prior notice. Osama Bin Laden, the Taliban and Somali Pirates did not hand diplomatic ultimatums to British embassies. And in any case, the ‘Ostrich’ approach in the 1930’s caused us no end of trouble.

Public opinion is important. Britain has been largely succesful in its foreign interventions since Suez in 1956, and while public opinion quite rightly recoils at the sight of Union Jack draped coffins arriving home, there is also a feeling that all the time we are succesful, spending money on defence is justified. Failures, however, would bring this under the spotlight.

To achieve any kind of over-arching policy it is vital that the 3 services somehow manage to co-operate more and stop squabbling over funding and resources. This is partly as a result of Whitehall’s ‘divide and conquer’ approach to running the armed forces. But would it really be too much to ask for an Air Marshal to admit that we need Chinooks not Eurofighters, or for an Admiral to concede that we need smaller, flexible carriers and more frigates and destoyers?

We might doubt exactly how much influence the UK has over the US in terms of defence. If our generals had been listened to before the Iraq war, much of the debacle that ensued afterwards might have been avoided (see General Sir Mike Jackson’s memoirs). But on the other hand, the 1982 Falklands War, and Britain’s convincing success against the odds, had an almost immeasurable effect upon the United States military.

While much of our defence policy will be heavily scrutinised, Britain still has an influence on the world stage out of all proportion to its size. Whether, and how, this can be maintained is another matter.



Filed under Afghanistan, Army, debate, Falklands War, Navy, News, politics, Royal Air Force

11 responses to “Britain ‘faces world choice’

  1. Hi colleagues, nice article and good urging
    commented here, I am in fact enjoying by these.

  2. Genuinely no matter if someone doesn’t understand then
    its up to other people that they will assist, so here it

  3. I leave a comment when I especially enjoy a article on a
    website or if I have something to contribute to the conversation.
    Usually it’s a result of the fire displayed in the post I looked at.
    And on this article Britain faces world choice | Daly History Blog.

    I was actually excited enough to create a comment 🙂 I do have some questions for you if you usually do not mind.
    Could it be only me or does it seem like a
    few of these comments come across like they are written by brain dead individuals?
    😛 And, if you are posting on other online sites, I’d like to follow you.

    Could you list every one of your public sites like your Facebook page, twitter feed, or linkedin profile?

  4. Numerous people have a misconception that costlier the
    app, much more helpful it is. What’s even better, though,
    is an unlocked Iphone 3GS. The Apple iphone has
    8 GB of constructed-in memory.

  5. Soderbergh follows intersecting reports all revolving around the drug war.
    You’ll also be incurred according to the period of the online streaming.
    The story is approximately Jack and Jill that are twins,
    both played by Adam Sandler.

  6. Devoted 24/7 Assistance Group in UAE US and Uk . All you require to do is select all the
    tunes that you require to transfer and choose the option for
    transfer. First things initial, you need to prepare your

  7. They’ve lesson plans for grades K through 12, and for children with special needs.
    Wizards are especially common during Halloween. I love this “Plants in the Yard” page because it only features a rectangular planter
    and some stems.

  8. This is good, provided that you eventually update to the current iOS.
    When you get a call, the song that you pay attention to
    may be the ringtone. Move on your notebook or iPad and switch
    on the Wifi adapter.

  9. ” Today’s Internet Marketing world allows you to create and implement a marketing strategy for your product or service for very little money, especially when compared to traditional advertising models. The Council in Brigantine will now consist of 3 Democrats and 3 Republicans with a Republican Mayor Philip Guenther. In such a case, you have two options-remove the person from your following list or respond to the person’s tweets with the hope that the person would notice you and start following you.

  10. Apple’s celebration demonstrated a fresh verve. Now what do you do if you believe all this velocity is too much to ask for?
    Would you feel just like the elements pattern has been doing a ditch?

  11. There is also speculation of the iPad Mini becoming launched at the same occasion. As we deleted the chat log frequently, much more
    and more fragmented files generated. You don’t believe it can get any
    better, but it can.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s