PM ‘refused extra Afghan troops’

General Sir Richard Dannatt

General Sir Richard Dannatt

Prime Minister Gordon Brown ignored military chiefs advice and refused a reinforcement of British troops in Afghanistan, the former head of the Army has said.

General Sir Richard Dannatt, who made himself very unpopular in Whitehall with his straight talking manner, told the Sun that ministers had to be taken “screaming and kicking” to agree to necessary measures, and that for some time the military had been operating “at least part of one arm tied behind one’s back”.

Of course Downing Street has come out and denied the claims, effectively calling General Dannatt a liar. Whilst Dannatt was still in office civil servants were briefing against him, no doubt unhappy with his frank statements about the lack of funding and equipment for the armed forces. He would normally have been a candidate for promotion to Chief of the Defence Staff, but this was vetoed by the Prime Minister.

If more reinforcements are needed, and the Government is – for whatever reason – unwilling to approve them, then they should put pressure on our NATO allies, some of whom are contributing very little at the moment. In one sense the Government is right to be careful about troop increases, as we are overstretched as it is. In a sense more British troops would only add added pressure.

But there are bigger issues than troop increases here. The armed forces may have a duty to follow the direction of the Government, but they also have an equally important duty to their men and women below them. The fact remains that our servicemen and women are being asked to put their life on the line, and soldiers respect commanders who stand up for them with the politicians. Some things go beyong party politics, and defence policy should be one of them. It is a dangerous precedent to set for Generals who speak the truth as they see it to be hounded out of office for not following the party line. This happened frequently in the first world war – generals who didnt say what the government wanted to hear were fired. And Winston Churchill himself was notoriously impatient with his Generals.

Hopefully Richard Dannatt will publish his memoirs. They would make very interesting reading indeed.



Filed under Afghanistan, Army, debate, News, politics

28 responses to “PM ‘refused extra Afghan troops’

  1. tonanti216

    As you suggest, the sooner his book the better! Roll on the book! What never ceases to amaze me is the capacity of this Government to lie and spin as it does… do they really think that we will all think that it’s General Dannatt who is lying? I hope General Richards is as robust as Sir Richard was.

  2. dalyhistory

    Hi tonanti, thanks for your comment. I think Dannatt’s frank speaking has surprised many precisely because for years the Government has sought to brow-beat senior officers, and turned the forces against each other to compete for funding. Since the creation of the MOD it seems that to reach high command you have to keep your head down and toe the line.

    Dannatt has obviously not upset the establishment too much as the Queen saw fit to appoint him Constable of the Tower of London, and he is now Chairman of the Royal United Services Institute, so its clearly only the politicians who have a problem with him.

  3. The initial “game” to play would be to hand-out envelopes because the guests come in.
    Then you can certainly have baby shower games that element scavenger hunts.
    Colors will be noticed by your infant very in early stages.

  4. The guide itself is extremely small, and also the learning curve with this game really
    is not all that steep. You need to defend the bottom at all costs!
    FameTown is made with a start-up in La named Diversion.

  5. At the core of the farmville expertise is planting and
    harvesting plants. We used it to show the list of your friend’s superior results in Sheep Magnate.
    Then select friends to deliver demands to.

  6. One good way to strengthen your protection from ACL injuries is to wear knee braces Ottawa physicians
    recommend. Most people try to find a club or team that
    does agility training and then train in their off time at home.
    Injury prevention occurs because you are enlisting more of your muscles
    to pitch in on the work that you are doing, thus lessening the wear and tear on individual muscles
    and their associated tendons and ligaments.

  7. Professional – Three of the play selections need you to
    have attained professional score. After knowing my dependency was heavy and probably
    harmful I’d to become authentic with myself.

  8. It is also among the hardest what to learn in virtually any language.

    Stay at a desk or on to the floor with the infant and the Clipo games.
    I never got paid; the newspaper folded soon afterwards.

  9. It’s an remarkable article in support of all the internet visitors; they will get benefit from it I am sure.

  10. When you see the message” prepare to jailbreak (DFU)”, then plug your
    gadget to a Pc. That could mean that the jailbreak would
    be launched on Feb. 3, or Tremendous Bowl XLVII Sunday.

  11. Start the nite install once more if you had to set up .Net Framework.
    The security widget will scan block and eliminate malware.
    The Android BBM app will launch at 7 a.m. So you can obtain as many
    tunes as you like.

  12. The iPad 2 had an excellent present of 1,024 x 768.
    None of this changes my fervent need to own an iPad. With this particular info you should be able to locate
    where to get an iPad 2.

  13. The Huawei Ascend D-Quad was initially identified at MWC in March.
    You must spend some prices for downloading the flicks.
    It is accessible only in metallic silver, and dark.
    Not really a year old yet, it’s expanded exponentally.

  14. The music that you choose is likely to be setup by AT&T
    as your iPhone’s ringback tone. For more technology news, gadget reviews, and
    tips and techniques, checkout my news blog, GizmoGuide.

  15. To be certain, 2013 would have been a large year for change
    and I hope you accompany me along for the drive. The tree informs URL To save Hyrule’s property from a looming
    evil that’s nearly displayed itself.

  16. Just to “bump” things a little… have you considered any coverage of the 1914-18 Mesopotamia campaign? I have just started to try and piece together my grandfathers travails from enlistment in the 1/5th Hampshires when he lived in Portsmouth and so far find him moving to the 1/6th and “Mespot”…. all very complicated and of course intresting to see how Turkey was drawn into battle….

  17. I have been browsing online more than 4 hours today, yet I never found
    any inteeesting article like yours. It’s pretty worth enough for me.
    Personally, iff all websote owners and bloggers made good content as you did,
    the intewrnet will be much more useful than ever before.

  18. I like the valuable information you supply for your articles.
    I will bookmark your weblog and check once more here regularly.
    I am slightly certain I will be informed a lot
    of new stuff right right here! Good luck for the next!

  19. Hello to every one, the contents present at this site are
    really amazing for people experience, well, keep up the good work fellows.

  20. If you have the SHSH blobs saved for iOS 4.two Beta three, you will see “SHSH: four.2b3” in the
    status. GV Mobile + is $2.99 on the App Shop, just as GV Link is.
    Clip your telephone to your belt, in a good vented pouch.

  21. The hash label will not show up within the Facebook update, incidentally!
    In this way you can improve your Facebook lovers.
    To be able to do this, you must discover ways to build a nice-looking Facebook

  22. Marketing afiliat trebuie să faci asta
    mai des .

  23. Consequently, a good small issue with your computer could end up being
    annoying. Microsoft provides different warnings also.
    To save your photo to local drive, clickDownloadand decide on a destination to
    save it.

  24. You also have types in order to find on the movies you would
    like to view with this amazing device. Perhaps they are meant to maintain male organization. The packets travel within least resistance’s route.

  25. Thanks for stopping by and if you know of any other apps we should check out make sure you share.
    Easily include and alter your contacts saved in the Get in touch
    with Administration databases.

  26. The it is possible to either evaluate the outcome oneself
    or email them off for your favorite support individual.
    So long as you’ve enough strength you can continue
    steadily to fight.

  27. Practic , conținutul este situat în jurul valorii de etichete speciale ,
    altfel denumite cuvinte cheie .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s