Tag Archives: Roy Urquhart

The (inceasingly tedious) historiography of Arnhem

I know its something I have written about before, but it never ceases to amaze me how historians and publishers will attempt to flog dead horses. Well, maybe thats not a great analogy, but some battles have been written about so much, without anything substantially ‘new’ being offered.

Coming from a background of academic history, my philosophy is that you only undertake to write something if you have a new vein of original material that has never been worked on before, or you can offer a dramatically new appraisal of something that has already been done. What you don’t do is just re-hash what somebody else has already done. It gets very tiring when you see yet another book about an epic battle, that promises much but delivers little.

Therefore I am astounded by just how many books get written about Arnhem and Market Garden. Most of them are very general books, telling any reader who has more than a little knowledge what they already know and offering nothing new in return. In Waterstones yesterday I picked up a copy of a new Arnhem book by a well-known military history duo, whose books I have previously enjoyed, but whose new effort on Arnhem appears to be re-inventing the wheel. It does seem to be publisher-motivated, as any military history publisher knows, books on Arnhem sell.

Out of the virtually hundreds of books written about Arnhem, only a handful of them are really indispensible, in my experience. Arnhem by Martin Middlebrook is the best overall, general introduction about the Battle. A Bridge too Far by Cornelius Ryan is, for obvious reasons, another good introduction, which reads almost like a novel, and takes a wider perspective. It never snows in September by Robert Kershaw is invaluable, as it is the only book that really tells the German side of the battle – and a history of a battle that only focuses on one side is like watching a football match but only being able to see half of the pitch. Arnhem 1944 by William Buckingham was, in my opinion, the first book to look at Arnhem through a more challenging, modern historiographical perspective. Even if you don’t agree with his conclusions, putting the cat amongs the pigeons leads for a more rigorous history in my opinion. And obviously ‘original’ texts like those by Roy Urquhart, John Frost etc are invaluable, as primary sources.

It’s so disappointing, to see big name authors with big publishing deals re-hashing what is already out there, when there are legions of historians out there who are working hard on original material, yet never get the credit that they deserve. As much as I want to sell books and pay the bills, I also want to contribute to history, and you do that by offering something new or different. I guess in that respect military history does lag behind some other disciplines, in that sometimes it is nowhere near challenging enough, and of course as a popular subject for publishing it is open to market forces more than say the history of ferret stuffing in deepest Somerset.

20 Comments

Filed under Arnhem, debate, historiography, Uncategorized, World War Two

Sandhurst Registers online

New College, Royal Military Academy Sandhurst

Sandhurst (Image via Wikipedia)

Earlier today I randomly stumbled on the Sandhurst Collection website, where you can download entries from the Royal Military Academy‘s registers. The database is searchable online, and a scan of each entry can be downloaded for a small fee.

The entries do not contain anything too juicy, but all the same they tell you when an officer cadet was there, their basic personal information, and useful information such as their father’s occupation. Although it doesn’t seem like much, used alongside registration records, census returns and subsequent Army lists it helps you pin down the early years of an officer’s career.

The entry’s wont include wartime emergency commission officers, sadly, as Sandhurst closed in 1939 for the duration of the war. Many pre-war and post-war officers can be found, however, including Winston Churchill, Bernard Montgomery, Alan Brooke, Frederick Browning and Roy Urquhart. Closer to home I have also found the entry for Major Robert Easton MBE DSO, from Portsmouth.

12 Comments

Filed under Army, Family History, Uncategorized, World War One, World War Two