Retreat and Rearguard 1914: The BEF’s actions from Mons to the Marne by Jerry Murland

I have always felt that perhaps the military history of the First World War has focussed far too much on the events of 1916 and 1917 – primarily, Verdun, the Somme and Passchendaele. Sure, all three were epic battles with a profound social and military impact, but viewing them without looking at what became before and after is to only see half of the picture. The British Expeditionary Force landed in France in August 1914, and marched up to the Belgian frontier. In defence of Belgian neutrality, the BEF marched into Belgium itself to meet the German Army’s advance.

I have studied something of the retreat from Mons, during my research into the 1st Hampshires and their battle at Le Cateau. But given that I am hoping to write a book or two on the First World War, I was very pleased to see this land on my doormat. I have always been mystified by the portrayal of Mons as a defeat. True, I think it would be hard to paint Mons itself as a victory, but Smith-Dorrien‘s decision to stand at Le Cateau was a masterpiece. Much like Quatre Bras almost a hundred years before, success there gave the rest of the Army time to slip away orderly. And although it is never inspiring for an army to retreat, a General should not be afraid to do so if the strategic situation demands it. French and the BEF had little option but to fall in line with Joffre’s overal strategy, particularly with an unreliable Lanzerac on the BEF’s right flank. The Duke of Wellington retreated many times, but almost always in an orderly fashion, with a plan up his sleeve. True, French might not exactly have had a Waterloo planned, but the retreat forced the German Army to over extend itself and to falter on the Marne. I think history would probably hold out that this was a far wiser strategy than to stand at Mons and be destroyed.

I feel a special mention is in order for the fighting at Etreux on 27 August 1914, where the 2nd Bn Royal Munster Fusiliers were attacked by the Germans at 7am near Chapeau Rouge, before a fighting withdrawal throughout the day, before a dramatic last stand at the Orchard in Etreux. The Battalion was decimated, and four of those killed were from Portsmouth – Lieutenant Challoner Chute (19), Lance Corporal Edward Carroll (29, Milton), and the two brothers Corporal Charles Roberts (23) and Corporal George Roberts (21),  of Meyrick Road in Stamshaw. I am very grateful to Jerry Murland for adding to me knowledge of how these Portsmouth men died.

Murland has made a fantatic contribution to the history of the BEF on the Western Front. Impeccably researched, it is based on a wealth of primary and secondary material. In particular I was very impressed with the maps, which really helped to gain a feel for the battles of August 1914. He has dealt very well not only with giving a full and insightful narrative of the campaign, but has also shed light on often overlooked areas – the relations between French, Haig and Smith-Dorrien, and between French and Joffre and Lanzerac; the myth that the BEF’s marksmanship was so rapid that the Germans thought that every man was armed with a machine gun; and he has also given new prominence to the sterling work of the gunners and sappers during the retreat.

A retreat in contact with the enemy is perhaps the most challenging military maneouvre to pull off – if it works, you have barely survived; if it fails, you have a rout. Not only was it a success for the BEF get itself back to the Marne in the state that it did, but it is also very commendable that Murland has looked at every last little aspect of the campaign in such a forensic yet fulsome manner. As good as John Terraine’s book on Mons is, I found Jerry Murland’s much more insightful.

Retreat and Rearguard 1914 is published by Pen and Sword

About these ads

21 Comments

Filed under Army, Book of the Week, portsmouth heroes, western front, World War One

21 responses to “Retreat and Rearguard 1914: The BEF’s actions from Mons to the Marne by Jerry Murland

  1. John Erickson

    I think the negative attitude about Mons comes at least partially from the fact that the troops moved out of prepared positions to the line at Mons, then had to fall back to those positions, thus seemingly going in circles. With my limited knowledge of WW1, I understand the maneuvers, and the military success of them, but I think most folk (who aren’t quite as … “dedicated” … as we are) don’t “get” all the events that made the move necessary, as well as successful.
    Feel free to substitute different terms for the word “dedicated”. In my case, “anal” popped to mind. ;)

  2. x

    I remember Holmes’ War Walk and how he described how the men of the Royal Fusiliers positively enjoyed their shooting at Nimy bridge. Wonderful stuff.

  3. Pingback: The Somme by Gary Sheffield « Daly History Blog

  4. Pingback: Forgotten Victory by Gary Sheffield « Daly History Blog

  5. What is the best program of motion to take? Whilst it
    appears odd to have a pc make your decision for
    you it could arrive in handy. Videos are a extremely popular feature in these modern times.

  6. Used cars are perfect for if you need car title loans financial assistance to serve your specific needs.

    Or you could opt for shortening of the loan amount.
    Luckily, federal law entitles you to one free credit report from each credit bureau every year.
    Besides ensuring a safe vehicle purchase, the dealer will cover a percentage of the original
    value of the goods that are being held in Japan,
    and getting all the formalities are successfully completed.

  7. Numerous people are jailbreaking their iPad2 to make it much better than before.
    Better to trade thoughts and settle issues now. Follow the
    steps to jailbreak the iPad with spirit.

  8. For instance, some tissues tell your body it may not make insulin (Type 1).
    If successful, new solutions can be developed that can reduce the damage to cure the condition at
    its creation.

  9. Nevertheless, you can confront some data loss, so I needed steps,
    if you screwup. In the event of double-hung windows, you are appealing these issues
    with open arms.

  10. This is my first time go to see at here and i am actually happy
    to read all at single place.

  11. This is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger.
    I have joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of
    your wonderful post. Also, I have shared your site in my social networks!

  12. Beneath are some the current head aches WhatsApp
    gives it legion of users. This revert back the lockscreen functionality.
    There are resources accessible to you that you can use to determine the loyalty and sincerity of your girlfriend.

  13. Be aware, you can also choose to replace your bootlogos right
    here in purchase. If you thought that twin-cores
    had been awesome, then the processor buzzing within the SIII is epic!
    I think a Twitter Detox is in store for this weekend!

  14. Pingback: Megagame: Iron Dice – Turn 1 | Themself

  15. Pingback: Megagame: Iron Dice – Turn 2 | Themself

  16. Pingback: Megagame: Iron Dice – Turn 4 | Themself

  17. Pingback: Megagame: Iron Dice – Turn 5 | Themself

  18. Pingback: Megagame: Iron Dice – Turn 6 | Themself

  19. Pingback: Megagame: Iron Dice – Turn 7 | Themself

  20. Pingback: Megagame: Iron Dice – Turn 9 | Themself

  21. Pingback: Megagame: Iron Dice – Turn 10 | Themself

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s