The Taylor Report unpicked: the terracing debate

Fans of Borussia Dortmund support their team e...

Dortmund's Westfalen Stadion (Image via Wikipedia)

In 1989 virtually all football grounds in Britain contained a sizeable portion of terracing. In fact, terracing was so synonymous with football, that it would have been impossible, prior to 1989, to imagine football without it.

Originally earth or cinder banking, rows of railway sleepers were placed on top to give a firm footing. Some earlier stadiums had had scaffold-like stands, until a collapse at Ibrox in 1902 killed many spectators. Gradually earth was replaced by stepped concrete. The wide expanse of these concrete terraces were broken up by metal crush barriers, which prevented surges and crushing – and also gave fans something convenient to lean on! Far more fans could be packed into an expanse of terracing than the equivalent area of seating, so the advantages to the clubs was obvious – more people, bigger crowds, more gate receipts.

Terraces were particularly popular among working class fans. It became traditional for a clubs most vociferous fans to stand on the terrace behind one of the goals. Standing is pro-active, whereas sitting is passive. Some terraces were covered and some were open, but no-one was particularly bothered if they got wet – it was all part of the experience. End terraces became held with great affection by fans – the Kop at Liverpool, the Holte End at Aston Villa, the North Bank at Arsenal and the Stretford End at Manchester United for example. At Fratton Park of course we had the famous Fratton End. There was also an area of the North Stand Terrace known as the ‘boilermakers hump’, where dockyard workers would gather (back in those days going to Football was a legitimate reason for leaving the yard early!).

During the boom years immediately after the Second World War thousands would crowd onto the terraces: one had to turn up at lunchtime to get a good spot for a three O’clock kick off. Clubs even employed crowd packers to move the fans around and get as many people in as possible. Footage exists of small children being passed over the heads of the crowd down to the front to get a better view. At the time few fans travelled to away games, but those that did could travel around the ground at will, moving from one end to the other at half time.

It is strange indeed that the Taylor Report outlawed terracing, especially after Taylor had stated that terracing is ‘not intrinsincally unsafe’. Terracing did not cause Hillsborough – bad policing of terracing caused Hillsborough. Sadly, it does all support the conclusion that Taylor was given a brief by the Government to ‘sort out’ football. Part of gentrifying football was the attack on its working class roots, and the terrace and its inhabitants were the most visible target for ‘cleaning up’.

Most German Football Stadia have what are dubbed ‘safe standing’ areas. One, the Westfalenstadion at Dortmund, houses almost 30,000 behind the goal. Usually one end, or a couple of blocks in one end, are terraced. This is highly safe terracing, with wide steps, a crush barrier for every couple of rows, and a sensible capacity so fans are not jammed in. FIFA and UEFA games must be all-seater, so clubs get round this by the simple expedient of either having ‘hybrid’ terracing, or terracing that is easily converted into seating. The Olympiastadion in Munch has terracing that gives each spectator a designated spot, and there is a seat built into the crash barrier behind that can be used if necessary. Even for standing games, this is convenient for half time. The Espirit Arena in Dusseldorf has terracing, with basic seats covered with a metal panel – this panel can be easily removed by ground staff. Dusseldorf is a particularly interesting example, in that when the stadium was completed in 2004, it was completely all seater. Terracing was retro-installed in 2010, due to pressure from fans. This shows that terracing CAN be retrofitted into modern all-seater stadia.

Given the Germans penchant for efficiency and health and safety, do we really think they would have terracing if it was that unsafe? I doubt it very much. I have felt far more safe standing on terraces in Germany than I do seated in England. Terracing is much more safe than having seating, but where fans stand up throughout the game anyway. If people want to stand up, why not just have terracing anyway, but do it properly?

The terracing of 1989 and Hillsborough cannot be judged against that of 2010. The perimeter fencing, excessive capacities, barbaric pen arrangements, poor policing and stewarding, lack of turnstiles, few crush barriers, poor crowd distribution and non-existant emergency procedures are light years away from the terracing I have seen in Germany. All of the aforementioned problems can be remedied without recourse to seating.

Terracing, with a sensible capacity, plenty of crush barriers, and well managed, is perfectly safe. I doubt very much whether there is any will to re-introduce terracing in English football – not from the clubs, the football authorities or the Government. Not only because it would restore football to its working class roots, but also because clubs have spent so much converting to all-seater, few would want the additional lay-out of bringing back terracing.

Have English football fans gone soft since the introduction of all-seater stadia? All the evidence would suggest so. It would have been unthinkable, years ago, for fans to complain about noise, or the lack of legroom, or if their seats aren’t nice and comfy. It was just part of the game. I have said it before and I’ll say it again, the move from standing to seated is along the lines of conscious to comatose; from supporter to consumer.

About these ads

13 Comments

Filed under social history, Uncategorized

13 responses to “The Taylor Report unpicked: the terracing debate

  1. John Erickson

    I have to ask your opinion on a horse-and-cart question. Do you think the elimination of terracing gentrified the audience, or vice-versa? Has the ever-increasing price of attendance (itself driven by a ruthless search for profit) shifted the audience demographic from “blue-collar” lower-income working class to a “better-off” middle class, who then demand better (more comfortable) seating? At the risk of sounding militant, it helps to know what started the problem if you’re looking for a fix. (I realise that several different causes could be contemporaneous – I’d be interested on your thoughts as to price driving the audience make-up or vice-versa.)

  2. James Daly

    Thats a good question. I don’t think I have ever come across any documents, articles, interviews etc from pre-Hillsborough where anyone advocates all-seater.

    The commercialisation of football is generally understood to have started when Sky TV began broadcasting and distributing their TV rights money to the clubs in the Premier League, which was formed at around the same time as Sky started in 1992.

    So to cut a long story short, I do think that in the first instance the abolition of terracing was motivated more by safety and social/class issues than money, but of course when the football commercial revolution kicked off soon afterwards the lucrative nature of seating was plain to see for the clubs and the authorities.

  3. Another thing I’ve really noticed is always that for many people, poor credit is the consequence of circumstances outside of their control.
    For instance they may are already saddled with an
    illness and as a consequence they have more bills going to collections.
    It could be due to a job loss or the inability to
    go to work. Sometimes divorce proceedings can really send the funds in the wrong direction.
    Thanks sharing your notions on this site.

  4. Hi! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering if you
    knew where I could locate a captcha plugin for my comment form?

    I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having problems finding one?

    Thanks a lot!

  5. It seems that no make a difference how many occasions consumers state they
    want to freedom to choose when it comes to their songs and devices,
    no business listens. Appear at the latest iPod, the Contact.
    It is a fantastic small gadget, skinny and like and sporting a extremely comfortable touchscreen.
    The only issue? It has limitations about what you can and cannot
    put on the device. Third-party programs designed specifically for the participant is a big no-no.

    Orb Live provides you an additional way of viewing live Tv on your Apple
    iPad. If you have a computer with an set up Tv tuner card, alongside with
    Orb Caster software, all live Tv content material can be broadcasted on to your iPad over a Wi-Fi
    network. Verify out the Orblive website for more particulars.

    Yesterday, Shanghai Every day wrote that a quantity of students of 5 other schools confirmed that they had been conscripted.
    Fearing later drawbacks in their research and occupations, most would not have fought
    back. The college students would be employed as full-fledged workers, which
    is opposite to Chinese legislation, the newspaper said.
    The radio station CNR noted that some colleges have even suspended
    classes in purchase to deliver college students to
    the factory. This kind of instruction has also come from local authorities agencies to support Foxconn.

    So which are the very best applications for iPhone 4?
    The number of applications compatible to Apple
    iphone that are accessible at the App Shop lies way past the thousand
    mark. This tends to make it extremely tough to choose the top 10 Iphone applications, or leading one
    hundred apps for that matter. The list of cool Apple iphone applications, which include utility applications,
    gaming applications, journey apps etc. offered below will make this daunting job fairly simpler for you.

    Though we did point out that $128 down to $98 isnt an astonishing
    reduction, in contrast to some other merchants who
    are promoting the telephone for $200, this offer is really tempting and is a tremendous intelligent move by the shop.

    As we know, jailbreaking permit users to set up software
    that is not authorized by Apple on their iPod Contact, Iphone, and iPad.
    Much more potent! No restrictions! Want to customize iPad 3 options?
    The ability to alter the appear of your iPad 3? At any time
    think of obtain any apps for iPad three even if they are not included the Application Store?
    Full manage of your iPad three? iPad three
    Jailbreak allows you to do anything that is possible to do with your iPad three.

    Meanwhile, in the Pc business HP, Lenova and just about everybody else is scrambled to toss with each other the
    required bits to create a gadget that closely resembles a pill or slate for “Rival Steve” to show running Windows 7 at CES, ahead of
    Apple’s (i)nnouncement.

    We’re all conscious of the method in which we are thoughtlessly plundering our all-natural sources, with drinking water being the
    most misused of the whole great deal. This precious app provides you
    details about the real amount of drinking water used in making our meals and
    beverages. The outcomes, at occasions, will outrage you, only to
    make you review your water consumption, and be much more cautious the
    next time you turn the tap on.

    It is just simple to perform DVD on iPad two with the above manual!
    And this manual also applies to changing and importing DVD to iPod/ Apple iphone
    4/iPhone 3GS/iPhone 3G/iMovie/Final Cut Pro/Final Cut Specific…

  6. Windows Media Player is generally available on most PC’s,
    since it is a part of Windows Operating-System.
    The video is all about the Shawshank Prison and their quest inside the walls of prison.

  7. A good move on one board may possibly not be a good move on
    the other. You should organize some gifts like gadgets, books and treats placed on a carpet.

    Most youngsters do not like math or like doing math
    on worksheets.

  8. From your Start button, click Run and type msconfig, then click OK.

  9. I have medical benefits, a pension program, four weeks trip, and that I receive money properly.
    There are a total range of sites offering final poker pro chips.
    Can you want to master most of the herbs?

  10. You could certainly see your expertise within the work you write.

    The sector hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who aren’t afraid to say how they believe.
    All the time follow your heart.

  11. It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to this outstanding blog!
    I suppose for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my
    Google account. I look forward to new updates and will talk about this blog with my Facebook group.
    Chat soon!

  12. Asking questions are actually pleasant thing if you are not understanding anything fully,
    however this article offers fastidious understanding even.

  13. Everything is very open with a clear clarification of the issues.
    It was truly informative. Your website is very helpful.
    Thank you for sharing!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s