Commando Tactics of the Second World War by Stephen Bull

As Stephen Bull quite rightly states in this book, the word ‘Commando‘ has become common currency for all kinds of special forces operations.

The ‘commando’ concept originated from the Boer War, when Dutch-descended ‘Kommando‘ units caused havoc for much larger British units in the South African veldt. Winston Churchill, who was a war correspondent at the time, recalled the idea in 1940. At the outset of the Second World War, Britain didn’t really ‘do’ special forces. The Commando’s were formed in 1940, partly by initiative amongst the armed forces, but also spurred on by characteristic notes that flourished from Winston Churchill demmanding instant action. The idea was that while Britain was unable to stike back at the enemy in a conventional manner, small groups of nimble special forces could inflict an impact on occupied Europe out of all proportion to their size.

Commando’s made their presence felt on the Lofoten Raids in Norway; at St Nazaire and Dieppe; on D-Day and in Siciliy and Italy. Strictly speaking the British Army C0mmandos were formed from volunteers from Army units, but the Royal Marines also formed their own Commando units later in the war. The Parachute Regiment was formed from No 2 Commando in 1940, and the SAS and SBS were formed by formed Commando officers. Thus it could be argued that the Commando’s formed their embryo for modern British special forces. Ironically, whilst the Royal Marine Commandos, Parachute Regiment, SAS and SBS still exist, the Army Commandos were disbanded soon after the war.

The title of this book focuses on tactics, but Bull goes much further by writing about the wider history of the Commandos, and the impact that the development of the Commando’s has had on British military ethos and development, the effects of which can still be seen today. But the real strength of this book is in the description of the making of a Commando – what went into selecting and training the men, the development of tactics and equipment, and how mistakes were made and lessons were learnt until a well-honed concept was arrived at. The ‘small, heavily armed but highly mobile’ approach has become widespread amongst all special forces to this day. There is also much in the selection and training that will be familiar to anyone who has read Bravo Two Zero or the million and one other SAS memoirs.

 This book adds considerably to the historiography of British special forces during the Second World War. It is an interesting read in its own right, but it also stands up extremely well as an in-depth military study. It contains some fascinating biographies of leading Commandos, and some useful eyewitness accounts. But the real piece de resitance is the inclusion of contemporary documents, such as details of Commando clothing and equipment, the establishment and armanent of Commando units, and a booklet describing Commando Battle Drill.

Commando Tactics of the Second World War is published by Pen and Sword

About these ads

16 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

16 responses to “Commando Tactics of the Second World War by Stephen Bull

  1. John Erickson

    James- Any idea if this book, or (what I assume is) the accompanying volume about British Infantry, is available over on this side of the pond? I know of a number of re-enactors over here who would love this as a source book. Does Mr. Bull make mention of some of the truly improvised features of the Commandos such as soliciting holiday snaps as recon for the Dieppe raid? (Yes, I know it was less creativity and FAR more desperation!) I’d like a copy of this to add to my Dieppe research library, since almost all of my information covers the Canadians during Dieppe, with only brief mentions of the British. (Forget about the Yank Rangers who participated, neither Canada nor the UK want to claim them!) See, nobody loves us brash Americans. ;)

  2. James Daly

    There is a sizeable section on Dieppe. It sounds to me like the only success story from Dieppe was the way in which the Commandos secured the flanks and assaulted flanking gun batteries.

    Something I neglected to mention in my review is the way in which the US Army studied the Commando concept carefully and borrowed from it for their own Rangers.

    Take a look at PnS’S Website John, I think they ship to the US. I would highly reccomend it to re-enactors, its got a lot on uniforms, tactics and such like.

    • John Erickson

      Hey, hey, don’t you go talking down my Rileys! The RHLI was the only Canadian unit to get into the town, unlike all those bums from western Canada! :p
      Seriously, I’ll have to dig on the P&S site, I didn’t see anything saying they ship across the pond. (To be fair, I didn’t see anything that said they don’t.) The only problem with books from Britain is the shipping is usually a killer!

  3. Pingback: make money tips

  4. Pingback: military watches

  5. But it’s a good idea to ask if car appraisal you can to the dealer
    trade-in value could result in a substantially larger down payment.
    Used car dealers are sleezeballs. This commands sufficient reflection and diligence when drawing up your used car loan.
    You should not get carried away. The most important thing to be kept
    in car appraisal mind is may determine the shape and condition usedcars.
    If you do not want to buy or lease?

  6. Cast Away-Tom Hanks gives a riveting performance in Robert Zemekis stranded-male-on-an isle-story.
    Mel Brooks is the grasp of parodies and Star Wars is probably the most popular movie franchise ever.

  7. Great work! This is the type of information that are meant to be shared
    across the net. Shame on the seek engines for now not positioning this put up higher!
    Come on over and visit my web site . Thank you =)

  8. As in any sport, training exercises assist in improving a person’s overall health and fitness and refine the particular capabilities required in their particular sport and playing position. Now, obviously, these are special ladies who put in a lot of extra effort to accomplish some specific goals,
    but it does make a point. Injury prevention occurs because you are
    enlisting more of your muscles to pitch in on the work that you
    are doing, thus lessening the wear and tear on individual muscles and their associated tendons and ligaments.

  9. From here, you are able to choose to watch an email simply by touching the notification. It’s
    the buyer who determines whether to jail break the pone or not.

    Likewise, browse by song, artist, album or
    genre.

  10. Hello, this weekend is good in support of me, for the reason that this moment i am reading this enormous educational piece
    of writing here at my home.

  11. Today I’ll present the AssistiveTouch on iOS to you and hope you want it.

    Wholesale iphone-5 cablesare also accessible online at an affordable price.

    Beneath The scan option could be the firmware once it is identified.

  12. Hi to all, how is all, I think every one is getting more from this web site, and your
    views are nice for new viewers.

  13. I’m curious to find out what blog system you are utilizing?
    I’m having some minor security problems with my latest site and I would like to
    find something more safeguarded. Do you have any recommendations?

  14. Ada

    Apple, being the creator of iPod Contact, has limited the capabilities of iPod Touch.
    Under the browse button will be the firmware as soon as it’s discovered.
    The applications below are completely among the best.

  15. Rather I have worked through my problems in more real ways.
    This is one particular resources that they are able to demand for,
    its simply that good. It is suspected that you’re running Windows
    2000, XP, Vista, or 7.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s