Churchill in Normandy by William Jordan

For me, one of the most amusing stories of the Second World War is the argument between Winston Churchill and King George VI. Churchill was keen to get into the action, in his usual schoolboy like way. The King, meanwhile, felt that if the Prime Minister went, he should too. Eventually, Eisenhower pressured both into backing down – the King’s private secretary informed his master that if he was to go he would have to advise his daughter on a choice of Prime Minister, should he and Churchill be killed. George VI then ordered that if he could not go, then the Prime Minister could not go either. One wonders if the King, normally shy and content to not interfere, made a show wanting to go merely to prevent Churchill going!

Churchill eventually got to visit the Normandy Bridgehead on 13 June 1944. After sailing across the Channel on the fast Destroyer HMS Kelvin, the Prime Minister and his party disembarked at Arromanches, landing on the shore in a DUKW amphibious vehicle. The historic meeting between Winston Churchill and General Montgomery, the Land Forces Commander for Overlord, was filmed by none other than the South African Prime Minister Field Marshal Smuts. Monty was no doubt keen to get the visit over and done with, due to his well-known dislike for VIP visits while he was trying to fight a battle!

From the D-Day beaches the group travelled by lunch to Monty’s forward tactical Headquarters at Creully. Monty had developed a system of an advanced headquarters during his time in North Africa, and in North West Europe his spartan existence consisted of three caravans, captured from the Italians in the Desert. One of them housed an array of maps relating to the military situation, and Churchill was treated to a ‘Monty special’ description of how the battle was progressing. The group then had lunch, at which point the Prime Minister enquired about where the front line was (3 miles away) and whether there was any risk of their lunch being interrupted by a German counter-attack (Monty did not think so). One almost wonders if Churchill was hoping for some kind of drama – it would certainly have been in keeping with his mischievous personality.

From Monty’s Headquarters the group travelled back to the sea, where Churchill, Brooke and Smuts boarded the launch of Admiral Vian, the commander of the British Naval task force for Operation Neptune. They were mobbed while on the dockside, and Churchill returned the cheers of the soldiers and sailors. From there they sailed off the other British and Canadian beaches.

One interesting episode occured when Churchill informed those present that he had never been onboard a Royal Navy ship while she was engaging the enemy. As a result he convinced the commanding officer of the Kelvin to try and let him board the monitor HMS Roberts while she was bombarding German positions ashore, something that was not possible due to the difficulty of climbing onboard. On the return journey, however, an ambition was fulfilled when HMS Kelvin briefly joined in the shore bombardment before crossing the Channel. It is unclear whether the bombardment was militarily necessary, or put on to satisfy the Prime Minister.

Another interesting aspect that Jordan looks at is the Mulberry Harbour – opportune, given that Churchill sailed through it to and from Normandy. The origin for Mulberry is often given as a well known note when Churchill wrote to Lord Mountbatten, the Chief of Combined Operations, suggesting transportable harbours. I haven’t been able to research this myself, but personally I doubt whether Churchill was the sole originator of the idea. Britain had a multitude of scientists and engineers working on all kinds of ideas, so its possible that the idea was already being worked on, and that Churchill’s note has been given more importance than it deserves. Something very similar happened with the creation of Britain’s Airborne Forces in 1940.

None the less, William Jordan gives us a very interesting view of how Mulberry was developed, its consituent parts, how it was assembled off Arromanches, and in particular how some parts of the plan went awry – several caissons sank in the wrong positions, for example, and it proved difficult to tow some of the roadways across the Channel. Mulberry was surely one of the triumphs of Operation Overlord, and played a significant part in getting the Allies firmly ashore in June 1944. Along with Hobarts Funnies and PLUTO, Mulberry seems to have been one of those projects that the British excelled at – although I suspect that, like in other cases, Churchill’s involvement has been overestimated.

This is a very interesting guide, none the less. It is impeccably well researched, and illustrated with some never-seen-before photographs, which can only ever be a good thing. I’m also very impressed with the map on the back cover, showing Churchill’s movements through the Arromanches anchorage and the layout and development of Mulberry – it helps the reader get a very firm handle on an episode that tells us much about Churchill the man. Maybe the narrative clings a little too closely to orthodoxy for my liking, but perhaps on the other hand a Pitkin Guide is not the place for revisionism!

Churchill in Normandy by William Jordan is published by Pitkin, part of The History Press

About these ads

16 Comments

Filed under Book of the Week, d-day, Uncategorized, World War Two

16 responses to “Churchill in Normandy by William Jordan

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Churchill in Normandy by William Jordan: -- Topsy.com

  2. Pingback: Churchill's 'History Of The Second World War'. Why It Still Matters. Part 1.

  3. Pingback: Was Douglas MacArthur a good general? - Page 11 - PeachParts Mercedes ShopForum

  4. Jailbreaking the Iphone four is possible with a number of tools like Limera1n, JailbreakMe, Blackra1n, and RedSn0w.
    Each Iphone 4 jailbreak tool offers a different way of breaking the gadget, and
    their capabilities vary as well. Well-liked tools can jailbreak
    new versions of the iOS, like the iOS 5. Even before the release of the
    Apple iphone four, jailbreaking has currently been a well-liked motion with
    previous models of the Apple iphone, because it enables you to do more with the gadget.
    Breaking makes your telephone more than just a product for communication.
    It becomes a multifaceted device able of a broad range of functions.

    However, because it is against their protocol, doesn’t mean that it’s unlawful.
    There are many actions that manufacturers would prefer that you didn’t
    do which are not unlawful. A decision in the
    United States in 2010 by the Library of Congress decreed that, indeed, unlocking
    your device is completely legal under what is recognized as the +Fair Use Doctrine+.

    Here is an additional extremely innovative software. With this app
    you can effortlessly recognize the name and other details about a tune,
    by just keeping out your telephone in front of the source exactly where the tune is being
    played. It also allows you buy that tune and share it with your buddies
    on Fb, twitter, etc., and it is totally free for download.

    It is a process that could take a couple of months. You should be
    ready to put in this much time. Financial issues is a various aspect altogether, and the financial package you require will totally depend on the suggestions you have, and the skill established that you possess.
    Once you are carried out making the app,
    you need to submit it to Apple in a specified format, and it will consider them
    a 7 days to get back to you. If your application has been approved, you are prepared to hit
    the marketplace and make some big bucks.

    There are occasions when a woman just needs to relax at the finish of a tiring working day and still
    wants to enjoy a gourmet food. The Seamless application is perfect to fulfill all those meals cravings that plague individuals with
    pitiable cooking abilities, or people who are too tired to
    cook, or people who’d, well, just instead have their foods delivered.
    Seamless operates in a number of cities and if
    you occur to reside in one of these, consider yourself blessed.

    jailbreak is utilized not only in ipod but also in iphone and ipad to accessibility enormous facilities.
    The function of a jailbreak depends on IOS
    working system. Some believe that utilizing jailbreak is an illegal apply.
    But below Digital Copyright Millennium Act (DCMA), a US copyright law, utilizing of jailbreak
    is authorized. Ipod contact jailbreak is thus not illegal. It stays authorized if all the downloading is produced with payment.
    If this downloading is carried out at totally free of price it gets
    to be illegal.

    A few weeks in the past Google decided to kick off the
    new year with a new branded telephone sold through its new online shop.
    you can now buy your phone directly from Google. By all accounts, the Nexus One is
    a good little Android device, similar in
    perform to an iPhone. Price without a agreement $529.

    If you want to attempt this out, you only have to go to an online
    shop and look for the best iPad movie downloads.
    This is certainly the portal that you ought to accessibility
    as it can offer an superb services. Usually, you will
    only be requested to spend about ten to 15 bucks depending on the movie.
    Anyway, the charges are not pricey so this is still extremely sensible.

    This Mirror Screen Protector stops just that.
    Resistant to erosion and finger-printing, it is detachable without residue mark.

    Crystal-clear and durable, this display protector is customized-designed to match your phone’s Lcd display.

    Even games can be pretty inexpensive, with premium games often promoting for $2.99-$6.99 and numerous
    great video games going for $1.ninety nine or cheaper.
    There are also plenty of free games, although you do require to appear out for freemium games that
    can finish up costing you much more with in-app buys than you might have paid out in
    the first location.

  5. The show was about 3 brother witches who came together
    to become the Charmed Ones or the Energy of Three.
    Therefore, if you should be into these types of movies,
    be sure to understand this one.

  6. Jailbreaking a 4 also permits more modification. It automatically posts
    for your Twitter consideration.

  7. Nonetheless, issues like that do come up, and it takes time for solutions to
    arrive. While they are security holes, they are also the way that
    hackers produce jailbreaks. Initial, the product arrives with an impressive reward.

  8. It is the exact same as getting the product for free. If you have mistreated your 2G, you
    can discover Apple iphone 2G replacement locations on-line.

    After your gadget is jailbroken, you require to download Winterboard.

  9. It Is the period again, a brand new iPhone discharge is imminent.

    Now remove the phone from the pc and start the phone.
    The qualified Tokyo judge rejected the argument from Apple
    to be erroneous.

  10. There are numerous other types of Apple iphone consumer applications as well.
    Yup, apparently its heading to function on the iPad. There are some issues that you may
    encounter with this method.

  11. She predicts that there will be approximately
    200 million Apple smartphones sold by subsequent yr. Anyone can set up host and can handle or update his/her archive to share it with the neighborhood.

  12. It has more attributes and functions than any other devices.
    Before they get married, she desires to speak out some
    things she’s worried about. That is why we require quick access to
    the camera.

  13. Why in the world can you devote your money tomorrow in a-game which could
    disappear? Do they think that they’re being smart by being obscure?
    Some of the fresh accessories we received are listed below.

  14. I was very happy to uncover this web site. I want to
    to thank you for ones time due to this fantastic read!! I definitely really liked every part of it
    and i also have you saved as a favorite to look at new stuff
    in your blog.

  15. You can still function the older XP software in your new Windows 7 by changing it to XP
    function. Individual URLs is likely to make us better
    to find on Facebook.

  16. I know this web site gives quality based articles and other data, iis
    there any other site which offers these data in quality?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s