The Fields of Death by Simon Scarrow

Like me – and, indeed, thousands of others out there – Simon Scarrow is obviously a big Sharpe fan. This book is the final instalment in his lightly-fictionalised series on the careers of Wellington and Napoleon.

The story of Wellington and Napoleon’s military careers is an epic one, and for the most part Scarrow does not overcook what are fantastic stories in the first place – the Peninsular War, the battles of Asspern, Essling and Wagram, the Invasion of Russia, the Battle of Borodino, the retreat from Moscow, the Battle of Leipzig and Napoleon’s defeat and abdication in 1814, before his return and final defeat at Waterloo.

The reader is left with a feeling that Napoleon, early in his career a gifted general, gradually became a tyrant, exactly of the kind that he fought to overthrow during the revolution. And Scarrow’s depth of understanding when describing British contemporary politics is clearly very good. The description of diplomatic intrigue between charcaters such as Talleyrand, Fouche and Metternich is insightful – after all, a good historical novel should inform as much as it entertains. And Sharpe fans will enjoy the respectful nod to Bernard Cornwell’s famous character during the Battle of Vitoria – something that could so easily have gone wrong, but works.

There are several downsides, however. I feel that by calling the Duke of Wellington ‘Arthur’, Scarrow allows the reader to develop a sense of familiarity with the him, that the man himself would almost certainly have not allowed in real life, given his well known coldness and aloof nature. Most of Napoleon’s Marshals come across as bumbling, disloyal and incompetent – Soult and Davout in particular have not been kindly treated here, compared to history’s view of them.

But most notably, the fictional meeting between Wellington and Napoleon just after Waterloo just does not work, not for this reader anyway. Wellington had no desire to meet Napoleon, and there was nothing to negotiate anyway. The great advantage of historical fiction is that the writer can take historical license. But in order to work and ring true; it has to be believable… which, sadly, is not the case here. But this is a difficult story to write, as anyone who picks it up is bound to know what the ending is. So its not surprising that Scarrow has looked for ways to freshen it up.

About these ads

14 Comments

Filed under Army, fiction, Napoleonic War, Uncategorized

14 responses to “The Fields of Death by Simon Scarrow

  1. Most facilities in this part of the state are built with an understanding
    that these forces may come into play, but this particular building was required to do more.
    The initial meetings with the professional will take in all the details of how many family members there are,
    their requirements etc, and how much space should be given over to living rooms, bathrooms and kitchens
    etc. Your architect MUST look at your project through your eyes.

  2. The iPad is currently becoming assembled by Foxconn, the exact same company that manufactures Apple’s iPod, Iphone and Mac Mini in its largest plant in Shenzhen,
    China. So much it is not accessible for the international marketplace, but it is
    still worth of getting a lesson about the iPad supported formats and
    how to convert DVD to H.264 MP4 for iPad on Mac.

    The stats came from someone who ought to know: Jay Freeman, the administrator of Cydia,
    the app store for jailbroken gadgets. Freeman stated that evasi0n is the fastest-adopted jailbreak of all time.
    He additional that, as of Thursday night, Cydia had received visits from 5.15 million iPhones, one.35 million iPads, and four hundred,
    000 iPod touches that were jailbroken with evasi0n.

    This 3D shooter is a mirror of the well-liked 1990′s hit traditional Wolfenstein.

    The sport play has sixty different levels that mix puzzle solving and killing Nazi’s.

    The detail on this sport is great for a initial person shooter on the iPhone, the controls are also very easy to use.

    Considering that the iPad is too pricey as an e-book reader, you should only go for it
    if you seek a pill Computer encounter. Even although Nook Color
    is regarded as a hybrid in between pill Pc and e-book
    reader, it cannot match up to the iPad in this division.
    So it is secure to go for Nook Colour if you seek a devoted ebook
    reader, and not an general pill Computer.

    The Apple iphone and Incite are each Wi-Fi and Blue Tooth suitable.
    Because both telephones are on AT&T’s blazing fast 3G network, the telephones perform at about
    the exact same speed for web and voice functions. Both plans price about
    the same, besides for the GPS navigation provided by the Incite,
    which will price you a small more. For price, LG wins at $200 less!
    This is an incredible financial savings offered how well the Incite’s features contend
    with Apple iphone. Think about that a 32GB microSD will operate you about $125 and a 16GB will cost you about $45.
    If you are comparing with the 8GB Iphone, you will save $100,
    but will have to add back in the $40 cost of an 8GB microSD; still a substantial financial savings.

    Movie Genie: Have you at any time gotten into an argument about
    who starred in a film or the last movie that some actor/actress
    was in? Film Genie has the solutions. Anybody acquainted with
    IMDB will love this application. It uses all of the info from IMDB and
    gives it a user interface. It is much faster to open up
    this app and lookup then to wait around for IMDB to load on the
    mobile Safari browser. The cost for Movie
    Genie is only $1.99 and it is well worth it. There is really
    only one con to this app and that is that it lacks the capability to cut, duplicate, and paste.

    Not truly a necessary feature, but it would be good to have.

    After clicking Next at the prior display, Redsn0w will give a series of instructions on
    how to place your device into DFU mode. When this display appears, adhere to the instructions which
    will involve urgent and releasing the house and energy buttons and
    numerous intervals. Be sure to follow the instructions precisely
    as they are offered.

    This truly isn’t a surprise contemplating that when the Iphone 3GS first arrived out there was talks starting of the subsequent
    Apple iphone right absent. What is interesting
    is the reality that the second era iPad could be out as early as the
    finish of this year. There’s rumors that it will be accessible with smaller sized OLED
    screens, which would allow it contend more with the
    likes of electronic readers like the Amazon Kindle (even though it appears
    to truly have dug into the Kindles market currently).

  3. Fantastic beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend
    your web site, how could i subscribe for a blog site? The account helped me
    a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear idea

  4. If you really want to purchase this Apple iphone 4
    then you must go for contract offers. This is one of the preferred
    methods that people personalize their iPhones.
    By breaking, you are actually tampering with your gadget.

  5. Great article! This is the type of info that are meant to be shared around
    the net. Shame on Google for now not positioning this publish higher!
    Come on over and consult with my site . Thank you =)

  6. Enjoy reading it. Structured off recent tests, Garcinia is utilized all over
    the world as a supplement for those experiencing
    some sort of obesity. It comes from the natural supply and does not have destructive compounds, preservatives or contaminants
    which could cause harm to your body. By formulated with hydroxycitric acid, this unique works
    as a fat blocker, which is vital for fat loss. Saffron Extract success
    stories helps individuals to reduce their very own appetites and trim down glucose or sugars
    craving. No more running to the kitchen any A quarter-hour to have a food.

    Really, the authentic Garcinia Cambogiawill help to stabilize the
    levels of a person stress human hormones. This assists to stop probable mental
    binge eating, which happens to be one of several cause reasons for extra pounds.

  7. The key difference is more within the vocabulary.
    It’s the traditionalist model cover but nevertheless
    it is in trend. This is important for the iPerformer who
    usually has gigs that will last for a long time.

  8. Or does it not matter since it doesn’t multiple-task anyway.
    I assumed it had been rather modest when I first checked
    out the iPad. It is not upgradeable to 4G (unlike the Xoom, that will receive a free LTE upgrade soon).

  9. That brings us to speak about both the parallels and the differences between your two pills.
    If you should be buying larger screen then your cell-phone
    or iPod has, then this is a good choice.

  10. We all know in regards to the iTunes App Store, but how many
    folks know there is an alternative solution? The melody
    which you choose is likely to be create by AT&T as your iPhone’s
    ringback tone.

  11. Of course, it waited before very end of the display
    to disclose the new iPad. Additionally, it includes a little bar and a hot tub
    to relaxing for residents. The Fooducate is free and on iPad, iPhone and
    Android.

  12. The initial is usually to delete Cydia which might imply deleting some
    tweaks that had been downloading from there too. I’ve
    been sharing business information, responding to comments, and
    retweeting other incredible issues out there.

  13. As the jailbreak ps3 arrived into the marketplace it was very nicely accepted by players around the
    globe. You can even drag them with your finger and have them crash with each single other.

  14. I like it when people get together and share views. Great blog, keep it up!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s