Stalingrad: How the Red Army triumped by Michael K. Jones

Stalingrad

German Officer: ‘I must compliment you on your street fighting. I fought at Stalingrad and this was a tougher battle’.

British Officer: ‘This was our first try, we’ll be much better next time’.

So went a conversation shortly after the fall of Arnhem Bridge. The quintessentially English response aside, this exchange illustrates perhaps one of the biggest problems for western historians of the Second World War. As brave and hard-fought battles such as El Alamein, Normandy and Arnhem were, compared to the millions clashing in the East, the war in the west was peripheral. And if the war in the east was the Schwerpunkt, the Battle of Stalingrad, as Michael K. Jones shows here, was the tipping point.

I must confess to not having done much reading about the Eastern Front in the Second World War. Aside from the fact that – naturally enough my attention has usually been drawn to the more British aspects of the war, I have found the Russian experience hard to fathom. Apart from the sheer numbers and the epic scale of the fighting from Barbarossa to Berlin, I have found that there are far too many ‘ov’s and ‘sky’s to keep track of!

Perhaps I’m not alone among western historians, and the broader public at large, in not having a brilliant grasp of events such as the titanic struggle at Stalingrad. Aside from the lack of Western involvement and the distance, until the fall of the Iron Curtain an ideological barrier prevented in depth-western study of Stalingrad. During and immediately after the war communist propaganda coloured events, then after the death of Stalin destalinisation affected history to the point where the city bearing his name was changed to Volgograd.

In this book Jones uses research techniques and a writing style very reminiscent of Martin Middlebrook – especially his use of veterans accounts. Of course, until relatively recently the official Soviet version of History has dominated our understanding of the battle, so this reinterpretation, using the words of the people who fought it, is long overdue. Their accounts slice through the lingering clouds of Soviet propaganda.

But what really impresses me about this book is the emphasis given to the psychological factors that allowed the Red Army to triumph against the odds. This is not a mere narrative of the battle. We are taken under the skin of the battle’s participants, including lucid studies of the characters of the respective commanders, Chuikov and Paulus. The most salient point in the book, for me, is the impact of Stalin’s famous Order 227 – no step backwards. It is sometimes hard for those of us who live in a democracy to fathom the motivations of the millions of men fighting in a climactic struggle between two totalitarian ideologies. But to grasp these motivations is more than halfway to getting a feel for exactly how the Red Army triumphed in the bitter street fighting – a form of war that requires iron will and determination.

Books such as Anthony Beevor’s and Alan Clark’s may have covered Stalingrad in extraordinary length, but Jones’s ability to dig deeper – in terms of use of Russian sources and his probing of them – yet also write lucidly, raises the bar.

Stalingrad: How the Red Army triumphed is published by Pen and Sword

About these ads

4 Comments

Filed under Book of the Week, Uncategorized, World War Two

4 responses to “Stalingrad: How the Red Army triumped by Michael K. Jones

  1. kel_hig

    Yes, there is still a lot of research to be done in relation to the Eastern Front – From your review it sounds as though Jones’s book makes an excellent contribution. Stalingrad was a crucial tipping point in the war, the point where the Red Army ‘broke’ the German Army, and the balance started to tip in their favour. I’ve been reading up on the Russian experiences of the Second World War myself recently as I’m giving some lectures related to the topic in a few weeks time. Another book I recently read and enjoyed was Nina Tumarkin’s “The Living and the Dead: The Rise and Fall of the Cult of World War II in Russia” (@ http://www.amazon.co.uk/Living-Dead-Rise-World-Russia/dp/0465041442/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1268261347&sr=1-1 )which looks at the propoaganda and some of the myths inherent in the memorialisation of World War II in the USSR (and the war victory is still viewed by many Russians today as legitimising the Stalinist system).

  2. James Daly

    Two other factors I think are important are geography and language. Obviously most of the documents relating to Stalingrad and the Eastern Front will be in Moscow, and in Russian. Not quite as easy as nipping up to Kew!

  3. Very quickly this site will be famous among all blogging people, due
    to it’s pleasant posts

  4. You will require the IMEI for doing all this. Who understood a big
    sale on a soon-to-be previous phone could forecast the newest design’s
    launch? You can track it from anyplace in the globe, as soon as you have the web.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s