The Face of Battle by John Keegan

I must confess to being quite tired of narrative military history. As much as ‘the history of…’ accounts are important, in that they are the building blocks of history, they can be rather dry and predictable. I much prefer to read books that either take a long view and look at trends, changes and continuities, or attempt to drill down and investigate mysteries, explode myths or answer questions.

Therefore I was pleasantly surprised to pick up this book by John Keegan for the princely sum of £2.99. John Keegan is one of the main figures in late twentieth century school of military historiography, alongside other figures such as Basil Liddell Hart, John Terraine and Michael Howard. Among Keegan’s books that I have read and enjoyed are Churchill’s Generals – a study of senior British Army officers in the Second World War – and Six Armies in Normandy – A look at the national contingents that fought in the Battle of Normandy.

I often feel that military histories that look at just one battle, at one particular point in time, are like listening to one particular second in a much longer symphony. What becomes before and after makes all the difference, by isolating it we remove it from its natural habitat. Therefore I much admire this work, which sees Keegan looking at the human experience of war over hundreds of years. To do this in detail is a tall order, so three case studies are used – Agincourt, Waterloo and The Somme. Each provides an extremely useful yardstick for comparison to what came before and what came after – what changed, and why? What stayed the same?

Keegan does very well to make some very complex events more understandable – such is the essence of well-written history, after all. An approach that I particularly like is breaking each battle down into the different kinds of combat that were experiences – ie at Agincourt various combinations of Archer, footsoldier and knight; at Waterloo infantry, cavalry and artillery; and at the Somme infantry, artilley and to a lesser extent machine gunners. What is noticeable is how the change in combat was motivated by technology – from Agincourt to Waterloo the development of gunpowder, and from Waterloo to the Somme by rifling, more efficient high explosives and machine guns.

Against this framework looks at more human factors – how the social composition of the armies in question evolved, and how the development of weapons changed the type of wounds that a soldier might expect to suffer. Keegan even considers such interesting points as historical trends in looting. A salient point, however, is one that seems obvious to us only after we read it – that over the time in question battles involve more and more people, over a bigger and bigger space, and lasted for longer and longer. Such was the evolution towards total war.

Critics of Keegan might point out that he gives little consideration to political factors, but personally I find his refreshing. Im not sure if any Tommy Atkins was particulary worried about politics when lying wounded in the Mud at Agincourt, Waterloo or the Somme. As important as Clausewitz’s maxim is about war being the pursuit of politics through other means, does politics really have to overshadow every facet of military history? If we are studying strategy, yes. But when it come to the face of battle, no.

My only criticism is that the Somme was coming up for 100 years ago, and thus Keegan’s arguments are somewhat adrift, bearing in mind we are now in the nuclear age. Perhaps a new edition including an example from the Second World War might be pertinent, and put the Somme in greater context than leaving it as a bookend?

About these ads

16 Comments

Filed under Book of the Week, historiography, Medieval history, Napoleonic War, World War One

16 responses to “The Face of Battle by John Keegan

  1. Add to that the change in roles of Officers! Great Review, Great Book, from the Veteran Perspective.

    One of my favorite quotes was the British Officer faced with a French Soldier coming over the wall to kill him: “I longed for my Sergeant, so I could give him his rifle to shoot him.”

    And thanks for the link. I wouldn’t have found your site otherwise.

  2. Today, I went to the beach front with my children.
    I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She put the shell to her ear and screamed.
    There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear.
    She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is entirely off
    topic but I had to tell someone!

  3. People looking for Aldo shoes for men and shoes for women can
    log on to shopatmajorbrands. Onine shoe shopping is
    very much in trejd these days. Running shoes are easy to be found in just about any sporting store, but shoes ffor specific sports like soccer may be limited.

  4. Sure, the car $4000 biggest advantage is the price. Well,
    in all actuality it helps them over the long haul.
    Before you even go looking for your perfect
    vehicle to take home your car the same day. It is up to you.
    This might not be. How do you negotiate with a” nice person” who simply refuses to be” as is” you
    may be unfamiliar with to get quotes.

  5. How would a family group perma-caught in the 1970s hold up in 1990s Los-Angeles?

    Right after I started downloading movies online I cancelled my subscription to netflix.

    No wonder they become among the best displays.

  6. This software works together with iPad, the Apple iPhone and Ipod Itouch.
    JoeIs iPhone From there-you’ll get all the play-lists on the source system.
    Once that is finished tap Return to Cydia.

  7. Telephones in totally ideal condition will get $250.
    It has usually been expected that iphone add-ons will be created.
    Any cellphone can be customized with a ringtone. The primary
    distinction is much more in the terminology.

  8. At this stage you’ll require to make certain your Iphone
    is plugged in to your computer and turned off. This Iphone
    situation is priced in between $35-$39. Reaping these
    benefits is most likely when you Jailbreak ipad.

  9. It is regarded as most fashionable cell telephone situation that is preferred by numerous.
    You can also unlock your gadget following jailbreaking it.
    The .three or .4 are contemporary firmware variations.

  10. It will assist your Apple iphone stand out in the crowd.

    Apple iphone is a useful gadget you can use whenever. In situation
    your Apple iphone will get locked, you truly do not need a new
    Iphone.

  11. Some might have revisions from conspicuous programmers and unknown hosts.
    This application could transfer diary, contacts, SMS, movie and audio-files on technique.
    Since Tango Remote is general, it looks great on all iOS products.

  12. Finally, read the additional controls by touching kit icon.

    You can jailbreak iOS 4.0.2 via Redsn0w and 4.0.1 can be
    jailbroken via jailbreakme 2.0. CNN’s Android pill software is lovely.

  13. So be cautious applying striped chocolate in this level.

    That money largely came from in software expenditures.

    At the primary of the farmville expertise is planting and harvesting herbs.

  14. Weak bones can fracture and break if you have osteoporosis.
    Now, obviously, these are special ladies who put in a
    lot of extra effort to accomplish some specific goals, but it
    does make a point. For a DE to succeed consistently he needs at least 80 Speed and 80 Acceleration for this
    event.

  15. To blow up a image on your display just push and maintain down. It desperately
    needs indicators for studying, typing, and online status.
    I have tested the plan myself, and I was extremely statisfied with my findings.

  16. Thanks designed for sharing such a fastidious idea, paragraph is good, thats why
    i have read it entirely

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s