Mons: The Retreat to Victory by John Terraine

Unlike a lot of miliary historians who have managed to make careers out of very limited expertise, John Terraine was no one-trick-pony. As well as an authorative history of the RAF in the Second World War, Terraine also authore an impressive history of the U-Boat wars between 1914 and 1945. But his specialist area does seem to have been in the First World War. As well a being a staunch defender of Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig, he also wrote a fascinating book on the Western Front in 1918, from the Kaiser offensive to the final victory on 11 November 1918.

Therefore this book, Mons: The Retreat to Victory, acts as an earlier bookend. It challenges many of our assumptions about the First World War, in partcular the common misconception that the whole of the period from 1914 to 1918 was spent sat in trenches. The initial phase of the war saw the British Expeditionary Force moving up into Belgium, fighting stiff battles at Mons and Le Cateau before withdrawing back in relatively good order. The Battles of Mons and Le Cateau have long been held up as disasters, but the analysis here is more balanced. Terraine suggests that the British Army gave the Germans a bloody nose indeed. Given that they were also outnumbered 3 to 1, the view of Mons as a disaster seems all the more strange/ Cavalry also played a part in the wars early battles, contrary to popular convention.

The Germans Schlieffen plan was blunted, partly by Von Moltke’s tinkering with the allocation of forces, and then by the bloody nose they received on the Marne. As Terraine argues, the German war plan needed a qick victory – anything less was a defeat. By preventing the Germans from reaching Paris the allies might have brought about stalemate for over 4 years, but they made an eventual German victory much less likely. British leadership and organisation may have wavered at times, but it is important to remember that this was an Army that was used to fighting imperial battles. The Boer war in particular provided many lessons, particulary regarding marksmanship.

As we might expect from a historian with broad interests, Terraine makes healthy comparisons with the past and the future. Mons was the first battle fought by the British Army in North West Europe since Waterloo in 1815 almost 100 years before, ironically not a million miles away. Terraine also reminds us that in 1940 another British Expeditionary Force marched into Belgium and was beated back – only in 1940 the mobility and firepower that the Wehrmacht deployed acted as a decisive force multiplier. By contrast, in 1914 the German advance was not so concentrated or as swift.

One major disappointment, however, is the lack of referencing. No matter how much of a luminary John Terraine was, it would have been useful to know what his sources were – citing your sources is one of the golden rules of writing history. Perhaps this was intended for a more general interest audience rather than acdemics, but even then a bibliography and brief endnotes would have given readers an indication of the broader context, and some ideas for further reading. This ommision lets down an otherwise brilliant book.

Mons: The Retreat to Victory is published by Pen and Sword

About these ads

26 Comments

Filed under Army, Book of the Week, World War One

26 responses to “Mons: The Retreat to Victory by John Terraine

  1. Pingback: The U-boat Wars: 1916-1945 (an Owl Book), John Terraine : Boat Articles

  2. FoŠ³ most recent news you have too go to see world wide web and
    on web I found this web sife as a best site for hottest updates.

  3. It is much more convenient and fast for students to get approved car finance.
    Use these valuable tips for making the best choice, as it demands a little bit of effort
    trying to find the car of your dream. You first should have an overflow container that is really such stacked on chronicle and estimate.
    If this is the preliminary tip.

  4. 6 What is the secret? Even a car jump starter used, high-end audio system at a much higher price and
    those in used car buying process. In most cases, you are none the wiser, how can you
    be sure that no odors have set in! This goes as high as the dominant BMW brand, a company with many patrons that call themselves Englewood
    used car dealer, also known as inspection
    sections, often take place online or in person. 2 So it’s car jump starter good to see
    the car.

  5. Ah, to be labelled certified car vinyl wrap pre-owned, always have your priorities in mind.
    A used car car vinyl wrap auction? Who and where can I donate to?

  6. Hi there everyone, it’s my first pay a visit at this web site, and post is in fact fruitful for me,
    keep up posting these content.

  7. Look for VIN stickers on body panels to see if they are not flat?
    Some sites provide numerous guidelines for private owners to post their cars for college or
    for moving purposes? Secured form is related to pledging of collateral, whereas unsecured
    form is the alternate option. Also inspect for any
    rust at the bottom? If you see waviness at the end
    of carquest the price of an extended warranty on
    the vehicle.

  8. The inventory of secondhand cars is more complicated than that of buying a car
    from thousands of choices. Used auto loans are the best
    when it comes to additional cars for the family or for the off-road adventurer
    in you? Look for the extended warranty plans with only genuine auto dealership companies.

    There are numerous agencies providing the services to the clients.
    First: car vision The first parameter to select a good used car dealer.
    Many people prefer to change their car at the best price for the car.

  9. The first thing you need to go car insurance through, but it is
    always a good idea for saving money. Reason #14:
    Japanese safety regulations: The Japanese roadworthy testing system is
    a positive for two reasons: 1 All Japanese vehicles are subjected to exhaustive bi-annual testing and mechanical checks
    to ensure they work properly. You can ask for deal papers of
    used car which is in accordance to your needs.

    You will just be giving the seller the upper hand if you are looking for brakes that seem to lope or have uneven braking
    at low speeds.

  10. What the heck i just read? The primary matter is
    to consult your doctor before making use of this supplement.

    The extract of Saffron Extract is accessible such as
    supplements and tablets and talking to a physician will provide you a obvious comprehension of the
    fact that will it suit you or not. This supplement typically matches the requirements of all the persons but differences
    are normally there. So, you have to just be sure you aren’t the main one that could not make use of
    this solution. Essential problem is concerning the dosage.
    It is advisable to question your medical professional in regards to
    the consumption and be certain about it authentic Saffron
    Extract.
    WOW.Nice read here. The best step to precisely how this product gets results is that
    it is a dual action diet product, and therefore functions
    as being an appetite suppressant plus a “fat burner”.
    This really ensures that it oxidizes fat skin
    cells by using anti-oxidants, and this leads to additional power
    for your needs – but only if you know how taking authentic Saffron Extract in the correct style.Virtually all diet supplements on the market today
    are made around reving up your metabolic rate, which is not really secure for most
    people – and that is why a lot more people decide to invest in Saffron Extract extract
    instead.

  11. Well, that response should really be very evident by
    now. Here you need certainly to visit Offers and locate
    the bundle to be erased.

  12. That Is needless to say the crux of the issue.
    They even have a lot of television shows for download too.
    I guess it is a matter of individual choice there. The ultimate tearjerker
    in terms of I’m concerned!

  13. You can view videos in quite similar way as you’d on your personal computer over
    the internet. Despite how unsure I’m to what the heck it is actually,
    one thing is for certain.

  14. Pursuits from tattoo studios to motorcycle places are
    on reality shows. Today they trust Hamels put them back in front of Ny and todo exactly the same thing.
    Your favorite Pinoy TV Shows, for instance!

  15. You can go with any according to his/her selection.
    Soul mates who come perilously close to never meeting.
    Once downloaded, just install and follow the instructions and
    you’re done.

  16. Apple iphone is a useful device you can use anytime.
    Yes, this is a easy one, looks just like the Apple’s alarm clock.
    Its range of headsets has been received well more than the years and Easycall continues
    the legacy.

  17. Apple has manufactured this Apple iphone using ios4 working system that is its personal product.
    The list, which was posted on Tuesday, has been defused so that
    not all device proprietor info is available.

  18. One good way to strengthen your protection from ACL injuries is to wear knee braces Ottawa physicians
    recommend. Considering how much strength and agility is needed
    to perform the largely gymnastics oriented pole tricks similar
    to what gymnasts do in the Olympics, more men will eventually
    participate. You can further divide arms into biceps,
    triceps, and shoulders; legs into hamstrings, quadriceps, and calf (gastrocnemius); and core into lower back, obliques, and rectus abdominus.

  19. Thankyou for checking out what I do believe is a few of the finest sites out there
    to get free printables! Utilize The zoo coloring pages to
    get a follow up project that demonstrates the animals observed on the visit.

  20. One basically drinks a lemonade type drink for ten days and
    this will help you lose weight, feel better and look better.

    But remember when you are preparing the master cleanse, you must use freshly squeezed
    lemon juice. Now this may sound too good to
    be true but Master cleanse can definitely bring your health back and protect you
    within a 10 days process of treatment.

  21. Why in the world can you invest your money tomorrow in agame that will disappear?
    Just do not stop me while I’m chatting, okay?
    For more farming enjoyment: go here to subscribe to my articles.

  22. ” Today’s Internet Marketing world allows you to create and implement a marketing strategy for your product or service for very little money, especially when compared to traditional advertising models. Yet, John Delavera insists that list-building is not the secret to a successful Internet business. No doubt I’d be stopped by the police for dangerous driving.

  23. I simply could not go away your site before suggesting that I really loved the
    standard information an individual provide to your
    guests? Is going to be back continuously
    to investigate cross-check new posts

  24. Ideally, so will the subsequent installment of the Apple iphone.

    For now, mark your territory outside the Apple gadget shops.
    But sometimes we unintentionally deleted or misplaced the WhatsApp
    Messenger chats?

  25. I rarely create remarks, but i did a few searching and wound up here Mons:
    The Retreat to Victory by John Terraine | Daly History Blog.

    And I actually do have a couple of questions for you
    if you do not mind. Is it just me or does it seem like some of the responses appear like left by brain dead
    individuals? :-P And, if you are posting on other social sites, I’d like
    to keep up with anything fresh you have to
    post. Would you make a list of every one of all your communal pages
    like your Facebook page, twitter feed, or linkedin profile?

  26. Very good information. Lucky me I discovered your site by chance (stumbleupon).
    I have saved it for later!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s