USN F-4 Phantom vs VPAF MiG 17/19 – Peter Davies

Phantom vs. MiGs

Phantom vs. MiGs

I am a big fan of Osprey’s Duel series of books. The approach of comparing two contemporary machines, that fought against each other, makes for a very good read. And by also looking at the men involved, Osprey are onto a winner. This book charts the ongoing battle fought between the US Navy’s Phantom fighters and the North Vietnamese MiG fighters in the later part of the Vietnam War.

The US Navy developed its Cold War aviation from its successes in the Pacific in the Second World War. The North Vietnamese, on the other hand, relied on significant Chinese and Soviet assistance. In the US Navy, ‘MiG killers’ became something of an elite within an elite. The US Navy’s Phantom’s performance was far superior to that of the US Air Force phantoms during the same period. After 1972 the US Navy’s statistics improved considerably, after more emphasis had been given to training crews in air combat. Originally designed as a stand-off interceptor, innovative Navy pilots showed that the Phantom could be used for dogfighting.

Interestingly, although one Phantom crew ended the Vietnam War having shot down 5 MiG’s, the next highest crews only accounted for two. In a highly intense war, that must have involved many missions, clearly many operations saw little action. It is, however, difficult to compare losses compared to the overall amount of aircraft deployed, as Hanoi has never released details of just how many MiG’s fought in the war.

One very interesting aspect that this book stresses, as early as the introduction, is to what extent do we compromise between technology and skill? This is all the more pertinent given the Cold War context. Particularly when it came to dogfighting, technology was useful but not the be all and end all. Aerial combat is an extremely complicated business, involving the aircraft itself, the weapons, electronics, and finally the crew themselves.

There are some disappointing aspects, however. The book focusses exclusively on Vietnam, to the exclusion of any other factors. Other air forces around the world were flying Phantoms and MiGs at the time – what was their approach? The more you separate history into little sections, the more compartmentalised it becomes. This book is about Vietnam, and rightly so – but a little more wider comparison would be a useful literary garnish.

Otherwise it is a great read. Packed with technical descriptions and specifications, and with a plethora of photographs and drawings, this should put the Phantom-MiG duel on the same level as Spitfire/Hurricane vs. Messerschmitt and Harrier vs. Mirage. The very essence of military aircraft is how they perform against their rivals, and the Duel series is an ideal way to showcase this.

There is a side story to this book too. Rowland White’s Phoenix Squadron, published earlier this year, describes how a British Fleet Air Arm Pilot went to America and saw that the US Navy’s Phantom training consisted of a number of experienced pilots, all telling their pupils different things. ‘This is how I flew in Vietnam!’ seems to have been the message, even if if it was a different message from room to room. According to White the British pilot submitted proposals on how to centralise the US Navy training and introduce more of a coherent policy. The result was the famed Top Gun programme.

To what extent was the Top Gun programme, of Tom Cruise fame, inspired by the less well-known but equally skilled Top Guns of the British Fleet Air Arm?

Published by Osprey Publishing

About these ads

16 Comments

Filed under Book of the Week, cold war

16 responses to “USN F-4 Phantom vs VPAF MiG 17/19 – Peter Davies

  1. Why viewers still make use of to read news papers when in this technological
    world the whole thing is accessible on net?

  2. They will usually sell parts for very cheap prices and in bulk quantities.
    The following will help you car & truck shop in negotiation.
    As such, one must judge by the car itself! Get a third-party mechanic to inspect
    the car for just a few years old. You can
    exploit these regional differences to your advantage, it is then the manufacturer’s responsibility to rectify the problem to avoid huge expenses, it is
    always a good idea to remain car & truck shop flexible.

  3. Fine way of explaining, and nice article to take information
    concerning my presentation focus, which i am going to
    convey in university.

  4. Several write off these movies as vampire movies as
    a result of a number of the policies they split.
    The Shining – A 1980 movie adaptation of Stephen King’s bestselling
    horror novel.

  5. Now go to Options -> General -> Network and you will notice something new – “Internet Tethering”.
    To acquire this software you first must jailbreak and install Cydia.

  6. So do yourself a large favor and download it free of charge at http://www.iobit.com/systemcare.html. Before
    long nevertheless it may tell you that you have a virus on your desktop.
    You need to be way too chaotic for all of this!

  7. Until then, here is a list of the confirmed canceled shows.
    Observe hoboes move faboo, and get in on a lawn floor of
    ‘urchin chic’. That is exactly what the 1984 video Nightmare on Elm Street is all about.

  8. You can subscribe to these websites and watch streaming movies
    on your Iphone. When faced with the problem of selecting what to make
    for dinner, I increasingly flip to my phone. You can get this at a cost of
    USD 1.ninety nine.

  9. Follow @ipaddenver on Twitter for up-to-the-minute sales,
    deals, opinions and news regarding the iPad. There are 1000s of applications that you could download within your unit.

  10. Hello Dear, are you actually visiting this web page regularly, if so after that you will without doubt get good knowledge.

  11. The suspect advised the prey he had a gun and demanded the iPod or else he’d
    take the target. I’m within my mid-thirties, having a-day career as an IT-Specialist.
    Microsoft didn’t think of the primary operating-system.

  12. As soon as youare within the command prompt, type in powercfg
    /energy and watch for the 60-minute energy check to complete.
    These shutters are an easy task to retain even yet in a moist atmosphere and are extremely durable.

  13. Hello, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one
    and i was just curious if you get a lot of spam responses?
    If so how do you prevent it, any plugin or anything you can advise?
    I get so much lately it’s driving me mad so any support is very much appreciated.

  14. You will have the best TV occasion with all the same.
    Maria Friedman is the best Narrator, and Donny Osmond is
    the Ernest that is better. You will look for a view
    to suit you in a fair value.

  15. Literal Bears I am Jealous Of is called to be the most effective amusing
    website of them all. That by itself can drive people away, MySpace is meant to
    be a site, right?

  16. And in case, your data wander off by using iTunes you are able to regain them.

    It had been hoisted having a crane and carefully
    put onto the flatbed. Nonetheless it was just a
    rouse within the bargain.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s