Afghanistan in the News

Theres has been renewed intensity in the reporting of British forces role in Afghanistan recently.

Only on Monday the Prime Minister announced that 500 more troops would be deployed, taking the total number of British personnel deployed in Afghanistan to over 10,000. This comes in line with the US committing an extra 35,000 troops to the country, in a move not dis-similar to the ‘surge’ in Iraq seveal years ago.

As well as the 500 British troops NATO countries have pledged 5,000 troops, among them Turkey, Slovakia, Georgia and Portugal. There are still, however, some notable large European countries who seem unwilling to let their troops do anything too dangerous.

In announcing the new deployments, Gordon Brown spoke of dealing with the Taliban threat at its source – on the Pakistan-Afghan border. This strikes at the heart of the issue of why we are there. To pull out and leave a vacuum would be naive in the extreme. A lawless Afghanistan would destabilise Pakistan, a nuclear country that already has a multitude of internal problems. Meanwhile, to the west Iran is becoming incresingly belligerent. This is a region that cannot afford any more problems than it already has. And this is before we talk about the amount of heroin on Britain’s streets that floods in from Afghanistan.

Attitudes about the mission in Afghanistan are generally quite wrong. People labour under the misapprehension that we are somehow trying to conquer Afghanistan, which is clearly not true. Or, perhaps, they have fashionable but ludicrous and completely unfounded views that we are helping the US to exploit Afghanistan and that our troops are ‘babykillers’. It does not suit the UK, the US or any other country to be there one day longer than they have to be. Besides, there is nothing in Afghanistan to exploit. The goal is clearly to secure the country, fend off terrorist elements and enable the Afghans to take care of their own country. Reconstruction is the key. Help make Afghanistan peaceful, secure and prosperous, and we eliminate the Taliban’s raison d-etre and our own reason for being there. When countries collapse more often than not dangerous regimes fill the vacuum.

Ill-informed commentators draw comparisons between earlier wars in Afghanistan, but to even try to compare them is a grave mistake. Huw Davies makes an excellent case for this. The modern army is one that is used to working with civilians, fighting terrorists, and keeping the peace. Even in 1841, the British Army was not trying to conquer Afghanistan, merely to secure it as a strong from against Russian threats to India. The same kind of issues have been discussed in a recent Osprey guide, which I reviewed earlier this week.

Comparisons are useful in history, but not when there is no common ground at all. The only similarities between the nineteenth century wars in Afghanistan and today are the terrain, the conditions, and the culture. History gives us some valuable lessons in this respect. Protesters vaguely talk about earlier failures, which were in fact nothing of the sort – merely difficult campaigns that eventually achieved their objectives. Afghanistan is not a war without an end – people frequently said the same things about Northern Ireland and Iraq. Maybe there needs to be better information about what exactly our aims are, and the Afghan Government needs to do its bit too, as well as notable NATO countries who could contribute a lot more.

Whereas the war in Iraq was badly handled (particularly the immediate post-war phase), distracted attention from Afghanistan and had dubious effect on us here in the UK, it would take a naive person indeed to argue that the Taliban coming to power would have no effect on stability in the region or on our safety here in the UK. It is a very unpleasant business and it would be much better if we didnt have to be there at all, but history shows us that sometimes to stand back and do nothing solves nothing.

About these ads

23 Comments

Filed under Afghanistan, Army, News, politics

23 responses to “Afghanistan in the News

  1. So always check the paper work of maintenance that has been down the beaten path for quite some car + hotel
    time.

  2. When you can compare notes with all the terms and conditions.
    In Canada CarProof offers a comprehensive report on the
    car. If the dealer does not like this idea, he/she is offering junk.
    There are often signals verbal and non verbal given in the
    registration document is car 66 games correct.

  3. Some are indeed cuting edge and offr a new range of configurability.
    It is one of the best casinos in terms oof promotions and entertainment, and
    even some of the best performers have their shows right at the casino.
    Nowadays, most typical casino gamers who ply offline and online would probably tell
    you that they have found online casinos to be more player-friendly than
    ever before.

  4. Little by little, thhe body weight will dreop
    off, andd you could just pick up a couple of
    good habits in the process. A high quantity of ghrelin combined with a low amount of leptin equals weight gain.
    Rest aboutt 30 or so seconds and run that hill again.

  5. A genuine winner to get her to open up up a bit? The best way to use
    pick up lines and avoid using tacky types is to be ready.

    Frequently you will find something to chuckle about.

  6. This is good whenever you have places to go or have long-travel times to get anywhere.
    The video runs around 1 hour and 40 minutes and is rated PG.
    Mumble is just a penguin who does not need a heart song.

  7. Remember, there are lots of auditions for Disney channel shows, if you do not land the position, just keep trying.
    I’ve loved viewing Arthur previously, though it is
    more directed toward elementary-school aged children.

  8. Este mensajero cuestión está disponible en Inicio de Windows, Android, Iphone y de forma gratuita.
    Muchos confundido con una aplicación de fútbol, ​​pero se dirige a una gran cantidad de actividades deportivas.

  9. Still on the privacy issues, WhatsApp is once more found
    pants down. Sending SMS is an previous tale now but
    there are nonetheless limits on SMS sending & receiving.
    You can also backup the data and restore them later.

  10. It is one of many must-see movies of 2010.
    It gives some of the best models who want to be Victoria’s Secret 1010 supermodels.
    There are a lot of them that you can download for your iPod.

  11. The initial group to have each participant ranking victories.
    Both groups are trying to find their 10th win with a feasible 11 prior to the
    bowl games also come. Look for a website using a whole 24×7
    company plan.

  12. Lou

    Even more therapeutic will be the kneading the dough until it is smooth and elastic.
    Discover coloring pages that the children will like. This entertaining website I used last year for my
    children.

  13. You can use the restore command in the iTunes plan.

    With a two mega pixel camera you can take decent photos with the
    device as nicely. This case constructe from easy, treated silicone that resists dirt
    and stains.

  14. This package attaches to the sunlight visor of your vehicle, and features a photo voltaic powered batter.
    However, the picture looks gloomy this time round for Apple.
    For those who want to jailbreak apple iphone 3g, pay attention up.

  15. Apple has made some good improvements on costs
    for the two iPhones. My friend chooses the droid because it is on the T-Mobile Community.
    If you find his factors suspicious, fall out of the deal correct absent.

  16. In contrast, I rarely defeat gta vice city Vehicle IVis story mode in less
    than 30 hours. They’re provided in a variety of point
    increments and invite you to do numerous items using the Xbox online.

  17. Collection a few as well as ribbon or raffia.
    They’ve some wonderful color pages of Snowwhite and the Seven Dwarfs.
    Last year we presented our oldest daughter (then 4 years-old)
    to 2 of her half sisters.

  18. Many children do not like math or like doing math on worksheets.
    Next punch two holes in the the top of pipe and tie the string through them.
    Yes these games are very important on your sanity.

  19. You will find Clipo games are retailers like Target.

    This particular piece zips inside the back and may certainly keep carefully the cold out and the fashion in. Shower time is really a fun time for child too.

  20. First “Heir” winner Richard Hatch has become the precursor of reality TV legal
    issues. Because it requires iBoot or a bootrom this jailbreak
    isn’t on the iPad2 -stage exploit to install.

  21. Doublecheck to make sure that every one of one’s info is
    backed up before going to the next step. For a
    simple photo, struck the camera button without
    selecting Effects selection.

  22. My spouse and I stumbled over here from a different website and
    thought I might as well check things out. I
    like what I see so now i am following you. Look forward
    to exploring your web page for a second time.

  23. I take pleasure in, result in I found just what I was looking for.
    You’ve ended my 4 day lengthy hunt! God Bless you man. Have
    a nice day. Bye

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s