The Anglo-Afghan Wars 1839-1919 – Gregory Fremont-Barnes

The Anglo-Afghan Wars 1839-1919

The Anglo-Afghan Wars 1839-1919

On a recent visit to Pakistan, a British military official wondered out loud why the Pakistani Army was having such trouble fighting tribal militants in the Waziristan hinterland areas. After all, the British Army was fighting exactly the same war, in exactly the same place, in the 1930′s. The training manuals are still there to be read.

This story might be apocryphal, but it does illustrate how it simply will not do to shut past events in the past and forget about them. Particularly in military history, lessons are there to be learnt. Weapons may change, but terrains and societies remain relatively unchanged. The British soldier in Helmand province fixes Bayonets and clears compounds much the same as his ancestors did in the 19th century.

Therefore, this edition in Osprey’s Essential Histories series is very timely. At a time when many commentators are doubting our role in Afghanistan and whether we can achieve our goals – usually peppered with simplistic comments such as ‘the Russians couldnt manage it’ and ‘we couldnt defeat the Afghans in the nineteenth century’. This book certainly blows apart some misleading assumptions.

Gregory Fremont-Barnes is a Doctor in Modern History and a senior lecturer in War Studies at Sandhurst. Therefore, you probably couldn’t hope for a better qualified writer. And his background is crucial – this is not nostalgic history, it will make essential reading for young – and indeed older – officers serving in Afghanistan today.

The British Army has been fighting in Afghanistan since 1839, not too many years since Waterloo. British interest in Afghanistan arose from fears that Russia, just to the north, might threaten India, the jewel in the crown of the British Empire. Therefore repeated attempts were made to secure Afghanistan as a bulwark against Russian ambitions. Much as in the same way security in Afghanistan today is crucial to the security of Pakistan, and the wider region.

As with so many British campaigns, involvement in Afghanistan was hallmarked by initial failures, followed by which the local leadership rallied and secured the situation. Therefore, popular talk about the British Army failing in Afghanistan is largely inaccurate. The British Army was not trying to conquer Afghanistan, the strategic aim was to secure the north west flank of India, something that was achieved. Whilst Afghanistan has frequently been a hard fight for British soldiers, it has given some heroic tales, such as the Battle of Maiwand.

The overarching lesson from Britain’s experiences in Afghanistan seems to be that the real challenge lies in defeating the irregular forces at large in the country is a complex problem, that can be contained by military force but ultimately will be nullified by a sound ‘hearts and minds’ policy. And above all, an understanding of Afghanistan’s history, topography and society is crucial.

ISAF is not trying to conquer Afghanistan, that is the crucial difference. To do so would be impossible and counter-productive, as shown in this book. That such a learned and well-presented view is espoused by one of the very people instructing our future Army officers is very encouraging indeed. This book is well researched – as shown by the exhaustive bibliography – and contains Ospreys trademark detailed maps and fine artwork.

The Anglo Afghan Wars 1839-1919 is published by Osprey Books

About these ads

10 Comments

Filed under Afghanistan, Book of the Week, debate

10 responses to “The Anglo-Afghan Wars 1839-1919 – Gregory Fremont-Barnes

  1. Pingback: Afghanistan in the News « Daly History Blog

  2. Whilst they are safety holes, they are also the way that hackers produce jailbreaks.
    Buy one to maintain your favorite blackberry 8900 from dust, scratch.
    It is accessible only in black, and black with yellow.

  3. First is the current iPad two which will remained unchanged but receive a cost reduce to compete with competitors
    with a reduce price point like the Amazon Hearth.

    A Broadcom BCM5973KFBGH Microcontroller was used for the touchscreen, and a
    Broadcom BCM5974 CKFBGH capacitative touchscreen controller as nicely, which is the same combination as with the iPad
    one. Apple should have been happy with the results.

    For those blind individuals who are worried about the touch display becoming tough to use, there is nothing
    to worry about. Blind individuals can glide a finger over the display,
    and as they glide their fingers, the options will be spoken aloud.
    When the customers hear an option that they
    want to choose, they can tap their fingers on that choice twice, and the option will then be selected.
    There is no barrier to us blind people using the Apple iPads touch screen.

    Those seeking to jailbreak their gadgets require to make sure
    they are on iOS five..1 initial. Common of any jailbreak, customers are warned NOT to upgrade their gadgets if Apple releases a new iOS version,
    till an “all-clear” is given from the hacking teams indicating that either
    Absinthe A5 continues to work on the new version, or that a new jailbreak
    was created.

    Dropbox: If you have an iPad, you are likely to have a laptop
    and a Pc as well. Using Dropbox will conserve you all the trouble to trying to
    transfer information from 1 instrument to an additional using a pen drive.

    Once you install Dropbox and configure it, any file you have to your
    Dropbox account will be automatically saved to your Apple iphone, iPad,
    laptop computer, Computer, and also on the Dropbox.
    Also, you can download Dropbox for totally free!

    iPhone 3GS Black Elite Car Charger with Intelligent Display &
    IC Chip Protection: Simple, elite and totally mobile.
    The two-colour Lcd indicator, ninety levels adjustable
    tip, side rubber grips, complete metal tips and contacts make charging your Apple iphone simpler than at any time.
    Just purchase this vehicle adapter to power your Apple
    iphone on the go.

    The new iMac is incredibly thin. It appears thin sufficient to cut bread with (5mm, eighty percent
    thinner than the final iMac). “There’s an whole pc in here,” Schiller joked.

    Though we did mention that $128 down to $98 isnt an astonishing
    reduction, in contrast to some other merchants
    who are promoting the telephone for $200, this offer is really tempting and is a tremendous intelligent transfer by the shop.

    Livestrongs Myplate calorie tracker is a calorie and physical exercise logging tool, available
    for $2.99. This mobile app gives you an approximated daily calorie consumption
    that works to help you reach your diet, weight loss and meet your health and fitness
    objectives. Nevertheless, it will not advise you when to physical exercise or how
    to consume or anything much more than how numerous calories
    you ought to net in a working day.

    Meanwhile, much more and more more and more seem to doubt whether or not
    the judgment of the California courtroom is right.
    Each Apple and Samsung, in the previous, have been worldwide with various patent lawsuits.
    Samsung has now taken dominance of the cellular
    gadget market. Apple hopes to acquire ground with
    the Iphone five release date, which is scheduled for Sept.
    21st.

  4. I do not even know the way I finished up here, but I thought this
    post used to be good. I don’t recognise who you’re however
    certainly you’re going to a well-known blogger in
    case you aren’t already. Cheers!

  5. 2) you like so much watching movies, especially thrillers;
    it is your activity. He finds, love, respect and hard-work really
    does pay off. You can imagine how the rest plays out.

  6. Here are what I believe to be the five greatest TV series on DVD.

    Get your popcorn ready and check out each of the new movies in January alone, coming out for our pleasure!

  7. There’s even an internet service community where people as if you could promote and
    keep eachother accountable. And hey, we haven’t outlined
    the specs of both editions however.

  8. Apple also bans apps that assistance the donation of cash to nonprofit organization and charity groups.
    But the Apple iphone only works with iTunes, and iTunes won’t run on Ubuntu.

  9. When The reinstallation is completed, you’ll be able to
    continue with creating of the personal hotspot. Listed Here Is explaining about equally to save you from those annoying calls.

  10. View hoboes get faboo, and be in on the ground floor of ‘urchin
    chic’. Several movies you will can get on the online sites are really bootleg videos.
    It truly is somewhat successful and safe.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s